Interdisciplinary Center Psychopathology and Emotion Regulation, University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands.
J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2019 Aug;60(8):825-827. doi: 10.1111/jcpp.13097.
The importance of promoting child and adolescent mental health seems self-evident. However, child and adolescent psychologists and psychiatrists are not necessarily in agreement with each other about what promoting mental health means, the desirability of intervening to influence development, and whether improving mental health promotion justifies reducing young people's autonomy. If expressed and discussed openly, diverging views and opinions about these issues can be constructive and deepen insights. Philosophical discussions about the belief systems and their relation to theoretical models underlying specific research questions, methodological choices, and interpretations of findings raise awareness of the inherent subjectivity of mental health evidence and research, and stimulate 'clear thinking', arguably the most valuable implement in any scientist's toolbox.
促进儿童和青少年心理健康的重要性似乎不言而喻。然而,儿童和青少年心理学家与精神病学家对于促进心理健康的含义、进行干预以影响发展的可取性,以及改善心理健康促进是否证明减少年轻人的自主性是合理的等问题,意见未必一致。如果这些不同观点和意见能够公开表达和讨论,就可能具有建设性,并加深人们的认识。关于信念体系及其与特定研究问题、方法选择和研究结果解释背后的理论模型之间关系的哲学讨论,使人们认识到心理健康证据和研究的固有主观性,并激发“清晰思考”,这可以说是任何科学家工具包中最有价值的工具。