Department of Psychology, University of Georgia, Athens, GA.
Division of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry & Psychology, MetroHealth Medical Center, School of Medicine, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH.
J Dev Behav Pediatr. 2019 Sep;40(7):493-500. doi: 10.1097/DBP.0000000000000691.
Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) screening completion rates are often low despite their validity and influence on earlier intervention and positive treatment outcomes. This study sought to examine the use of one ASD screening tool, the Modified Checklist for Autism in Toddlers-Revised (MCHAT-R), in a racially and ethnically diverse urban pediatric clinic to review potential disparities within screening rates and referral practices.
A retrospective chart review was conducted for children (N = 999) within the ages of 17 to 34 months seen for a well-child appointment at one of 3 pediatric clinics: a general pediatric clinic, resident pediatric clinic, and Hispanic pediatric clinic.
MCHAT-R screening completion rates were low for all clinics. There were no significant differences in MCHAT-R screening completion based on ethnicity; however, the percentage of children screening positive on the MCHAT-R was significantly higher for Hispanic versus non-Hispanic children. Referral practices were highly variable across positive screenings, and few children received the appropriate combination of referrals.
Ethnic disparities in ASD positive screening rates and inconsistent referrals represent a critical issue in current pediatric practice. There is a great need for the development of more culturally sensitive ASD screening instruments. Additionally, to help increase ASD screening rate and accuracy, as well as consistency in referrals, greater emphasis is needed on professional training, parental education, and technology use within pediatric clinics.
尽管自闭症谱系障碍(ASD)筛查具有有效性,并对早期干预和积极的治疗结果有影响,但完成率往往很低。本研究旨在检查在一个种族和民族多样化的城市儿科诊所中使用一种 ASD 筛查工具,即改良婴幼儿自闭症检查表修订版(MCHAT-R),以审查筛查率和转介实践中的潜在差异。
对在三个儿科诊所(普通儿科诊所、住院儿科诊所和西班牙裔儿科诊所)接受 17 至 34 个月龄的健康儿童就诊的 999 名儿童进行了回顾性图表审查。
所有诊所的 MCHAT-R 筛查完成率都很低。基于种族,MCHAT-R 筛查完成率没有显著差异;然而,在 MCHAT-R 上筛查呈阳性的儿童中,西班牙裔儿童的比例明显高于非西班牙裔儿童。阳性筛查的转介实践差异很大,很少有儿童接受了适当的联合转介。
ASD 阳性筛查率和转介不一致方面的种族差异是当前儿科实践中的一个关键问题。非常需要开发更具文化敏感性的 ASD 筛查工具。此外,为了提高 ASD 筛查率和准确性,以及转介的一致性,需要更加重视儿科诊所的专业培训、家长教育和技术使用。