Department of Urology, Mayo Clinic, Phoenix, Arizona.
Department of Urology, University of California Davis, Sacramento, California.
J Endourol. 2020 Jan;34(1):1-6. doi: 10.1089/end.2019.0292. Epub 2019 Sep 25.
Kidney stones affect 1 in every 11 people in the United States each year. There is a significant high recurrence rate without a stone prevention protocol. Alkali citrate is beneficial in decreasing stone recurrence, but because of the cost and gastrointestinal side effects there is a low adherence rate. This study aims to serve as a review of some of the most commonly used alkalizing over-the-counter supplements that are advertised to prevent and treat kidney stones. Data were gathered by a comprehensive online literature search and company inquiries for kidney stone prevention supplements. An additional informal poll of the authors selected supplements that are most commonly taken by their patients. A total of eight supplements were evaluated for cost, alkali equivalent provided, dosing, and regulatory information. Eight of the most commonly used supplements were reviewed with a focus on alkalizing agents. Information reviewed revealed dosing recommendations resulting in decreased citrate alkali equivalents per day compared with prescription-strength potassium citrate. Cost, peer-reviewed study results, and regulatory data were reviewed, tabulated, and analyzed. Cost per alkali equivalent was substantially decreased for each supplement compared with the prescribed drug. All supplements were found to be readily available online. Over-the-counter alkalizing agents are available to patients and may be an appropriate alternative to cost-prohibitive potassium citrate when treating urolithiasis patients. Additional testing will be necessary in the future to determine the efficacy of these supplements in the treatment and prevention of urinary stone disease.
肾结石影响美国每 11 人中就有 1 人,每年都会复发,如果没有结石预防方案,复发率会很高。柠檬酸钾有利于减少结石复发,但由于成本和胃肠道副作用,其依从性较低。本研究旨在对一些最常用于碱化的非处方补充剂进行综述,这些补充剂被宣传用于预防和治疗肾结石。通过全面的在线文献检索和公司查询肾结石预防补充剂来收集数据。作者还对一些最常被患者服用的补充剂进行了非正式的民意调查。总共评估了 8 种补充剂的成本、提供的碱当量、剂量和监管信息。对 8 种最常用的补充剂进行了综述,重点介绍了碱化剂。审查的信息显示,与处方强度的柠檬酸钾相比,剂量建议导致每天的柠檬酸盐碱当量减少。对成本、同行评议的研究结果和监管数据进行了审查、制表和分析。与处方药物相比,每个补充剂的碱当量成本都大大降低。所有补充剂都可以在网上轻松获得。非处方碱化剂可提供给患者,在治疗尿石症患者时,可能是成本较高的柠檬酸钾的合适替代品。未来还需要进行更多的测试,以确定这些补充剂在治疗和预防尿路结石疾病方面的疗效。