Sub-Directorate-General, Galician Health Service (Servicio Gallego de Salud - SERGAS), Galicia Regional Authority, Santiago de Compostela, Galicia, Spain.
Santiago de Compostela Health Area Authority, Galician Health Service, Santiago de Compostela, Galicia, Spain.
Implement Sci. 2019 Jul 24;14(1):75. doi: 10.1186/s13012-019-0924-0.
The study covered in- and out-of-hospital care in a region in north-western Spain. The intervention evaluated took the form of a change in the hospital drugs formulary. Before the intervention, the formulary contained four of the five low molecular weight heparins (LMWHs) marketed in Spain. The intervention consisted of withdrawing two LMWHs (bemiparin and dalteparin) from the formulary and restricting the use of another (tinzaparin), leaving only enoxaparin as an unrestricted prescription LMWH. Accordingly, the aim of this study was to evaluate the effect on in- and outpatient drug prescriptions of removing and restricting the use of several LMWHs in a hospital drugs formulary.
We used a natural, before-after, quasi-experimental design with a control group and monthly data from January 2011 to December 2016. Based on data drawn from official Public Health Service sources, the following dependent variables were extracted: defined daily doses (DDD) per 1000 inhabitants per day (DDD/TID), DDD per 100 stays per day, and expenditure per DDD.
The two compounds that were removed from the formulary registered an immediate decrease at both an intra- and out-of-hospital level (66.6% and 55.6% for bemiparin and 73.0% and 92.2% for dalteparin, respectively); similarly, the compound that was restricted also registered an immediate decrease (36.1% and 9.0% at the in- and outpatient levels, respectively); in contrast, the remaining LMWH (enoxaparin) registered an immediate, significant increase at both levels (44.9% and 32.6%, respectively). The intervention led to an immediate reduction of 6.8% and a change in trend in out-of-hospital cost/DDD; it also avoided an expenditure of €477,317.1 in the 21 months following the intervention.
The results indicate that changes made in a hospital drugs formulary towards more efficient medications may lead to better use of pharmacotherapeutic resources in its health catchment area.
本研究涵盖了西班牙西北部一个地区的院内和院外护理。所评估的干预措施形式是改变医院药物处方集。在干预之前,处方集中包含了在西班牙市场销售的五种低分子肝素(LMWHs)中的四种。干预措施包括从处方集中撤出两种 LMWHs(那屈肝素和达肝素),并限制另一种(亭扎肝素)的使用,只留下依诺肝素作为不受限制的处方 LMWH。因此,本研究的目的是评估在医院药物处方集中删除和限制几种 LMWH 的使用对门诊和住院药物处方的影响。
我们使用了一种自然的、前后对照、准实验设计,设有对照组,并使用 2011 年 1 月至 2016 年 12 月的每月数据。根据来自官方公共卫生服务机构的数据,提取了以下因变量:每千名居民每日限定日剂量(DDD)(DDD/TID)、每 100 次住院的 DDD 和每 DDD 支出。
从处方集中撤出的两种药物在院内和院外均立即出现下降(那屈肝素分别下降 66.6%和 55.6%,达肝素分别下降 73.0%和 92.2%);同样,被限制使用的药物也立即出现下降(门诊和住院水平分别下降 36.1%和 9.0%);相比之下,其余的 LMWH(依诺肝素)在两个水平上都立即出现了显著增加(分别为 44.9%和 32.6%)。干预措施导致院外成本/DDD 立即减少 6.8%,并改变了趋势;在干预后的 21 个月内,还避免了 477317.1 欧元的支出。
结果表明,医院药物处方集中朝着更有效药物的方向进行的改变可能导致其卫生服务区内药物治疗资源的更好利用。