School of Psychology, University of New South Wales.
Neuropsychology. 2019 Nov;33(8):1151-1162. doi: 10.1037/neu0000580. Epub 2019 Jul 25.
Although the presence of empathy deficits following traumatic brain injury (TBI) is well established, there is a paucity of research investigating the underpinning mechanisms. This study investigated whether feedback from posed emotional expressions and psychophysiological responsivity, thought to play a role in emotional empathy, are impaired after TBI.
Thirty adults with TBI and 30 demographically matched healthy controls completed 2 feedback tasks while skin conductance and heart rate were recorded. In Feedback Task 1, participants assumed different emotional postures and rated how this made them feel. In Feedback Task 2, participants held a smile or frown while viewing neutral images and rated the pleasantness of each image.
Participants with TBI did not differ from controls in their subjective ratings in response to posed emotional expressions. However, we found reduced skin conductance responses to rapid facial manipulations and some evidence of altered physiological arousal to sad emotional postures in participants with TBI. Finally, there was no relationship between emotional empathy and facial feedback or physiological responsivity.
We failed to replicate past research that demonstrated an impairment in the feedback effect in people with TBI. These normal subjective responses, though, were in the context of reduced psychophysiological responding to the posed expressions, suggesting that another mechanism can contribute to normal feedback effects after TBI. Finally, we did not find the expected relationship between the feedback effect and emotional empathy but may have been limited by the lower than expected rates of low emotional empathy in our sample. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2019 APA, all rights reserved).
尽管创伤性脑损伤(TBI)后存在共情缺陷已得到充分证实,但研究其潜在机制的研究却很少。本研究调查了 TBI 后,来自于模拟情绪表达的反馈以及被认为对情绪共情起作用的生理反应性是否存在缺陷。
30 名 TBI 患者和 30 名在人口统计学上匹配的健康对照组完成了 2 项反馈任务,同时记录皮肤电导和心率。在反馈任务 1 中,参与者摆出不同的情绪姿势,并对这些姿势使他们的感觉进行评分。在反馈任务 2 中,参与者在观看中性图像时保持微笑或皱眉,并对每张图像的愉悦程度进行评分。
TBI 患者在对模拟情绪表达的主观评分方面与对照组没有差异。然而,我们发现 TBI 患者对面部快速变化的皮肤电反应和对悲伤情绪姿势的生理唤醒反应存在一些变化。最后,情绪共情与面部反馈或生理反应性之间没有关系。
我们未能复制过去的研究结果,即 TBI 患者的反馈效应存在缺陷。尽管如此,这些正常的主观反应是在对模拟表情的生理反应减少的情况下出现的,这表明另一种机制可能有助于 TBI 后正常的反馈效应。最后,我们没有发现反馈效应与情绪共情之间的预期关系,但由于我们样本中情绪共情率低于预期,这可能受到限制。