Mannheimer Clas, Carlsson Carl-Axel
Clinic I, Vasa Hospital and Department of Neurosurgery, Sahlgren Hospital, Göteborg Sweden.
Pain. 1979 Jun;6(3):329-334. doi: 10.1016/0304-3959(79)90051-4.
Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TNS) was used on 20 patients with severe wrist pain due to rheumatoid arthritis. Three different stimulation frequencies were used: high 70 Hz stimulation (70 TNS), low frequency 3 Hz stimulation (3 TNS) and brief trains of stimuli with an internal frequency of 70 Hz and with a repetition rate of 3 Hz (3-70 TNS). The analgesic effect was evaluated on the patient's own estimate of pain relief and by means of a loading test in which the length of time the patient could hold a weight before and after TNS was used. The loading test and the patients' own estimate of pain relief corresponded well. After 70 TNS, 18 patients could double their loading time. The corresponding figure for 3-70 TNS was 16 patients and for 3 TNS 5 patients. The average duration of pain relief after cessation of stimulation was 18 h for 70 TNS and 15 h for 3-70 TNS, while those who responded to 3 TNS experienced pain relief for only 4 h on average.
经皮电神经刺激(TNS)用于20名因类风湿性关节炎导致严重腕部疼痛的患者。使用了三种不同的刺激频率:高频70Hz刺激(70TNS)、低频3Hz刺激(3TNS)以及内部频率为70Hz且重复率为3Hz的短串刺激(3 - 70TNS)。通过患者自身对疼痛缓解的估计以及通过负荷试验来评估镇痛效果,在负荷试验中测量使用TNS前后患者能够握住重物的时间长度。负荷试验结果与患者自身对疼痛缓解的估计结果相当吻合。70TNS治疗后,18名患者的负荷时间能够翻倍。3 - 70TNS治疗后的相应数字为16名患者,3TNS治疗后的相应数字为5名患者。刺激停止后,70TNS的平均疼痛缓解持续时间为18小时,3 - 70TNS为15小时,而对3TNS有反应的患者平均疼痛缓解时间仅为4小时。