Vetö Silvana
Universidad Andrés Bello.
Hist Psychol. 2019 Aug;22(3):244-265. doi: 10.1037/hop0000123.
This article deals with intelligence testing conducted at Santiago's Juvenile Court, in Chile, between 1929 and 1942. It is based on an analysis of 56 court records containing psychological or psychopedagogical reports filed by the Section for Observation and Classification at Santiago's House of Juveniles, an institution created in 1929 as part of the Juvenile Protection Law. To understand the purposes for juvenile intelligence testing in this field, several articles published at the time by the key actors involved in these institutions will also be analyzed. The results of this research signal, first, that psychology did indeed play a role in the juvenile justice system by laying the groundwork for the idea that it was necessary to measure and diagnose intelligence. The Binet-Simon Intelligence Scale, developed in France between 1904 and 1911 and adapted for Chile between 1922 and 1925, was systematically administered to juveniles in Santiago's Juvenile Court; the results were deployed as technical-scientific recommendations at the service of the presiding juvenile judge. On the one hand, this instrument, supposedly scientific and objective, helped legitimize the nascent field of psychology. On the other, it emerged as a useful tool in its own right to assess children. Second, the notions of intelligence underpinning these practices, while certainly in debt to the American approaches from which they were appropriated, managed to forge a more balanced stance between nature and nurture, positioning intelligence testing as a way of conceiving of and planning to prevent crime and reeducate juveniles. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2019 APA, all rights reserved).
本文探讨了1929年至1942年期间在智利圣地亚哥少年法庭进行的智力测试。它基于对56份法庭记录的分析,这些记录包含了圣地亚哥少年之家观察与分类部门提交的心理或心理教育报告,该机构于1929年作为少年保护法的一部分而设立。为了理解该领域少年智力测试的目的,还将分析当时这些机构的关键参与者发表的几篇文章。这项研究的结果表明,首先,心理学确实在少年司法系统中发挥了作用,为测量和诊断智力的必要性这一观念奠定了基础。1904年至1911年在法国开发并于1922年至1925年在智利进行改编的比内 - 西蒙智力量表,在圣地亚哥少年法庭被系统地应用于青少年;测试结果被用作技术科学建议,供少年主审法官参考。一方面,这个据称科学且客观的工具有助于使新兴的心理学领域合法化。另一方面,它本身也成为评估儿童的有用工具。其次,支撑这些实践的智力观念,虽然肯定借鉴了美国的方法,但在天性与教养之间设法形成了一种更为平衡的立场,将智力测试定位为一种构想和规划预防犯罪及对青少年进行再教育的方式。(PsycINFO数据库记录(c)2019美国心理学会,保留所有权利)