Division of Emergency Critical Care, Department of Emergency Medicine.
Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Department of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
Curr Opin Crit Care. 2019 Oct;25(5):517-522. doi: 10.1097/MCC.0000000000000644.
Change of practice in the ICU, particularly the discontinuation of approaches, which are no longer felt to be beneficial, can be challenging. This review will examine this issue and outline current thinking regarding how to best approach it.
Practices in medicine that do not provide patients benefit and possibly cause harm exist throughout medicine and are called low-value practices. Some low-value practices have successfully been removed from the ICU whereas others remain. The process of removing these practices from established care is often called deadoption. Low-value practices that are simply ineffective but produce comparatively less harm or cost, may represent a significant challenge to deadoption. Additionally, although no single intervention has been identified as the preferred method of deadoption of a low-value practice, we advocate for a multimodal approach.
Deadoption in the intensive care unit of practices that either cause harm or are significantly costly relative to their benefit remains an elusive goal. Attempts at deadoption should target local ICU circumstances, while still encompassing the spectrum of care outside the ICU, engage nursing more fully, promote the use of local champions, especially peers, and recognize the requirement to seek sustainability.
在 ICU 中改变实践,特别是停止那些不再被认为有益的方法,可能具有挑战性。这篇综述将探讨这个问题,并概述目前关于如何最好地处理这个问题的思路。
在医学中,存在着对患者没有益处、可能造成伤害的做法,这些做法被称为低价值做法。一些低价值的做法已经成功地从 ICU 中去除,而其他的则仍然存在。从既定的护理中去除这些做法的过程通常被称为废弃。那些仅仅是无效但相对危害或成本较小的低价值做法,可能对废弃构成重大挑战。此外,尽管没有一种单一的干预措施被确定为废弃低价值做法的首选方法,但我们提倡采取多模式方法。
在 ICU 中废弃那些造成伤害或相对昂贵但收益不大的做法仍然是一个难以实现的目标。废弃的尝试应该针对当地的 ICU 情况,同时仍然涵盖 ICU 之外的护理范围,更充分地让护理人员参与,促进使用当地的拥护者,特别是同行,并认识到寻求可持续性的必要性。