印度比哈尔邦公立卫生机构提供优质孕产妇和新生儿护理的准备情况:对地区医院和初级保健中心的横断面研究。
Readiness of public health facilities to provide quality maternal and newborn care across the state of Bihar, India: a cross-sectional study of district hospitals and primary health centres.
机构信息
Oxford Policy Management, Delhi, India.
Oxford Policy Management, Oxford, UK.
出版信息
BMJ Open. 2019 Jul 29;9(7):e028370. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-028370.
INTRODUCTION
Poor access to quality healthcare is one of the most important reasons of high maternal and neonatal mortality in India, particularly in poorer states like Bihar. India has implemented initiatives to promote institutional maternal deliveries. It is important to ensure that health facilities are adequately equipped and staffed to provide quality care for mothers and newborns.
METHODS
We conducted a cross-sectional study of 190 primary health centres (PHCs) and 36 district hospitals (DHs) across all districts in Bihar to assess the readiness of facilities to provide quality maternal and neonatal care. Infrastructure, equipment and supplies and staffing were assessed using the WHO service availability and readiness assessment and Indian public health standard guidelines. Additionally, we used household survey data to assess the quality of care reported by mothers delivering at study facilities.
RESULTS
PHCs and DHs were found to have 61% and 67% of the mandated structural components to provide maternal and neonatal care, on average, respectively. DHs were, on average, slightly better equipped in terms of infrastructure, equipment and supplies by comparison to PHCs. DHs were found to be inadequately prepared to provide neonatal care. Lack of recommended handwashing stations and bins at both DHs and PHCs suggested low levels of hygiene. Only half of the essential drugs were available in both DHs and PHCs. While no association was revealed between structural capacity and patient-reported quality of care, adequacy of staffing was positively associated with the quality of care in DHs.
CONCLUSION
Examining all DHs and a representative sample of PHCs in Bihar, this study revealed the gaps in structural components that need to be filled to provide quality care to mothers and newborns. Access to quality care is essential if progress in reducing maternal and neonatal mortality is to be achieved in this high-burden state.
简介
在印度,获得高质量医疗保健的机会有限是导致产妇和新生儿死亡率居高不下的最重要原因之一,尤其是在比哈尔邦等较贫困的邦。印度已经采取了一些举措来促进机构性的产妇分娩。确保卫生设施配备齐全且人员配备充足,以提供优质的母婴护理至关重要。
方法
我们对比哈尔邦所有地区的 190 个初级卫生中心(PHC)和 36 个地区医院(DH)进行了横断面研究,以评估这些设施提供优质母婴护理的准备情况。使用世界卫生组织(WHO)的服务提供和准备情况评估以及印度公共卫生标准指南评估基础设施、设备和用品以及人员配备情况。此外,我们还使用家庭调查数据评估了在研究设施分娩的产妇报告的护理质量。
结果
平均而言,PHC 和 DH 提供母婴护理的规定结构组成部分分别为 61%和 67%。基础设施、设备和用品方面,DH 平均而言略优于 PHC。DH 为新生儿提供护理的准备不足。DH 和 PHC 都缺乏推荐的洗手站和垃圾桶,表明卫生水平较低。DH 和 PHC 都只有一半的基本药物。虽然结构能力与患者报告的护理质量之间没有关联,但 DH 的人员配备充足与护理质量呈正相关。
结论
本研究检查了比哈尔邦的所有 DH 和具有代表性的 PHC 样本,揭示了需要填补的结构组成部分的差距,以向母婴提供优质护理。如果要在这个高负担的州实现降低产妇和新生儿死亡率的进展,就必须获得优质护理。