School of Management, Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, No. 11, Bei San Huan Dong Lu, Chaoyang District, Beijing, China.
China Center for Health Development Studies, Peking University, 38 Xueyuan Road, Haidian District, Beijing, China.
Health Policy Plan. 2019 Sep 1;34(7):483-491. doi: 10.1093/heapol/czz053.
The zero-markup drug policy (ZMDP) was heralded as the biggest reform to China's modern health system. However, there have been a very limited number of investigations of the ZMDP at county hospital level, and those limited county hospital studies have several limitations in terms of sample representativeness and study design. We investigated the overall and dynamic effects of ZMDP at traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) county hospitals. We obtained longitudinal data from all TCM county hospitals in 2004-16 and the implementation year of ZMDP for each hospital. We used differences-in-difference methods to identify the overall and dynamic effects of ZMDP. On average, the ZMDP reform was associated with the reduction in the share of revenue from drug sales (3.1%), revenue from western medicines sales (12.7%), revenue from medical care services (3.6%) and gross hospital revenue (3.4%), as well as increased government subsidies (24.4%). The ZMDP reform was not significantly associated with the number of annual outpatient and inpatient visits. In terms of dynamic effects, the share of revenue from drug sales decreased by 2.5% in the implementation year and by about 5% in the subsequent years. Revenue from western medicine sales fell substantially in the short term and continued to drop in the long term. Government subsidies went up strikingly in the short term and long term, and revenue from medical care services and gross revenue decreased only in the implementation year. The ZMDP achieved its stated goal through reducing the share of revenue from drug sales without disrupting the availability of healthcare services at TCM county hospitals. The success of ZMDP was mainly due to the huge growth in the government's financial investment in TCM hospitals.
零加成药物政策(ZMDP)被认为是中国现代卫生系统最大的改革。然而,针对县级医院的 ZMDP 进行的研究非常有限,而且这些有限的县级医院研究在样本代表性和研究设计方面存在一些局限性。我们调查了中医药县级医院 ZMDP 的总体和动态效应。我们从 2004 年至 2016 年的所有中医药县级医院获得了纵向数据,以及每家医院 ZMDP 的实施年份。我们使用差异中的差异方法来确定 ZMDP 的总体和动态效应。平均而言,ZMDP 改革与药品销售收入(3.1%)、西药销售收入(12.7%)、医疗服务收入(3.6%)和医院总收入(3.4%)的减少以及政府补贴(24.4%)的增加有关。ZMDP 改革与年门诊和住院人次的数量没有显著关系。就动态效应而言,药品销售收入的份额在实施当年下降了 2.5%,随后几年下降了约 5%。西药销售收入在短期内大幅下降,长期持续下降。政府补贴在短期内和长期内显著增加,医疗服务收入和总收入仅在实施当年下降。ZMDP 通过降低药品销售收入的份额实现了其既定目标,而不会扰乱中医药县级医院医疗服务的可及性。ZMDP 的成功主要归功于政府对中医药医院的财政投资大幅增长。