Oishi Hiroyuki, Tanaka Kanji, Watanabe Katsumi
Waseda University, Tokyo, Japan.
Waseda University, Tokyo, Japan; Kyushu University, Fukuoka, Japan.
Acta Psychol (Amst). 2019 Aug;199:102897. doi: 10.1016/j.actpsy.2019.102897. Epub 2019 Jul 28.
Sense of agency (SoA) is a subjective feeling that a person controls his/her own actions and causes changes in the external world. In continuous action such as controlling a dot by keypresses, SoA is influenced by actual actions during the task. Additionally, it is known that even though the actual actions were almost identical, outcome feedback (e.g., success or fail) could modulate SoA, indicating a retrospective modulation of SoA. However, it was unclear whether the SoA modulated by outcome feedback would influence SoA for an up-coming action. Here, we investigated the effects of outcome feedback in one-back trial on SoA in the present trial (i.e., prospective modulation). We conducted three experiments where participants controlled a dot to a target whose color changed unpredictably between white and blue. If the dot reached the target when the color was white (blue), participants received a text feedback of "Success" ("Fail"). However, in fact, we predetermined the outcome feedback to remove the effects of the actual performance of participants on SoA. The results showed that if the outcome feedback of the one-back trial was successful, SoA of the present trial became higher (i.e., prospective modulation) until they received the outcome feedback. Moreover, the prospectively modulated SoA was retrospectively overwritten by the outcome feedback of the present trial and likely converged to a constant level. These findings indicated that SoA was not produced by a mere sum of the prospective and retrospective factors, but rather that these factors independently influenced SoA with differential time courses.
能动感(SoA)是一种主观感受,即个人认为自己能够控制自身行为并使外部世界发生变化。在诸如通过按键控制一个点的连续动作中,能动感会受到任务执行过程中实际动作的影响。此外,已知即便实际动作几乎相同,结果反馈(例如,成功或失败)也能够调节能动感,这表明存在对能动感的回溯性调节。然而,尚不清楚由结果反馈调节的能动感是否会影响即将发生动作的能动感。在此,我们研究了单回溯试验中的结果反馈对当前试验中能动感的影响(即前瞻性调节)。我们进行了三项实验,让参与者将一个点控制到一个目标位置,目标颜色在白色和蓝色之间随机变化。如果点在颜色为白色(蓝色)时到达目标,参与者会收到“成功”(“失败”)的文本反馈。然而,实际上我们预先设定了结果反馈,以消除参与者实际表现对能动感的影响。结果表明,如果单回溯试验的结果反馈是成功的,那么在收到当前试验的结果反馈之前,当前试验的能动感会变得更高(即前瞻性调节)。此外,前瞻性调节的能动感会被当前试验的结果反馈回溯性改写,并可能收敛到一个稳定水平。这些发现表明,能动感并非仅仅由前瞻性和回溯性因素简单相加产生,而是这些因素在不同的时间进程中独立地影响着能动感。