Department of Neurosurgery, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, NY, USA.
Department of Neurosurgery, Mount Sinai Union Square, New York, NY, USA.
J Neurooncol. 2019 Sep;144(3):529-534. doi: 10.1007/s11060-019-03253-5. Epub 2019 Jul 31.
Surgical management strategies for glioblastoma (GBM) may differ among neurosurgeons with initial biopsy of suspected tumors and the need for early re-resection of tumors within 30 days of initial surgery. This study was initiated by the American Association of Neurological Surgeons (AANS) and Congress of Neurological Surgeons (CNS) Tumor Section's interest in understanding the rates at which pre- and post-resection procedures, specifically biopsies prior to definitive resection and early re-resections, are performed by U.S. neurosurgeons in the management of GBM.
A ten-question survey was distributed to members of the AANS/CNS Tumor Section.
The survey response rate among AANS/CNS Tumor Section surgeons was approximately 16%. Results showed that a majority of respondents performed surgery on 11-25 GBM cases annually. Of those cases, most neurosurgeons claimed that biopsies are rarely performed prior to tumor resection, but in the < 10% of cases for which biopsies are done, common reasons are to confirm radiological findings or improve the treatment plan. Likewise, re-resections are rare, but in the < 5 cases most neurosurgeons performed annually, common reasons included incomplete initial resections, referrals for greater resection, or unspecified reasons.
Further studies are needed to confirm the results of this study, which shows low rates of stereotactic and open biopsy and early re-resection procedures performed among neurosurgeons. These rates may help form guidelines in the treatment of GBM and encourage the use of surgical adjuncts that increase the extent of resection of these tumors, thereby reducing rates of early recurrence.
神经外科医生对胶质母细胞瘤(GBM)的手术治疗策略可能存在差异,具体取决于对疑似肿瘤的初始活检,以及是否需要在初始手术后 30 天内对肿瘤进行早期再次切除。本研究由美国神经外科学会(AANS)和神经外科学会(CNS)肿瘤分会发起,旨在了解美国神经外科医生在 GBM 治疗中进行术前和术后程序(特别是在明确切除前进行活检和早期再次切除)的比率。
向 AANS/CNS 肿瘤分会成员分发了十项问题的调查问卷。
AANS/CNS 肿瘤分会外科医生的调查回复率约为 16%。结果表明,大多数受访者每年进行 11-25 例 GBM 手术。在这些病例中,大多数神经外科医生表示,在肿瘤切除前很少进行活检,但在不到 10%的活检病例中,常见的原因是为了确认影像学发现或改善治疗计划。同样,再次切除也很少见,但在每年进行的不到 5 例病例中,常见的原因包括初次切除不完整、转诊进行更大程度的切除或未指定的原因。
需要进一步研究来证实本研究的结果,该研究显示神经外科医生进行立体定向和开放性活检以及早期再次切除的比率较低。这些比率可能有助于制定 GBM 的治疗指南,并鼓励使用增加这些肿瘤切除范围的手术辅助手段,从而降低早期复发的比率。