Speyer J L, Green M D, Kramer E, Rey M, Sanger J, Ward C, Dubin N, Ferrans V, Stecy P, Zeleniuch-Jacquotte A
Rita & Stanley Kaplan Cancer Center, New York.
N Engl J Med. 1988 Sep 22;319(12):745-52. doi: 10.1056/NEJM198809223191203.
Studies in animals suggest that the bispiperazinedione ICRF-187 can prevent the development of dose-related doxorubicin-induced cardiac toxicity. In a randomized trial in 92 women with advanced breast cancer, we compared treatment with fluorouracil, doxorubicin, and cyclophosphamide (FDC), given every 21 days, with the same regimen preceded by administration of ICRF-187 (FDC + ICRF-187). Patients were withdrawn from the study when cardiac toxicity developed or the cancer progressed. The mean cumulative dose of doxorubicin tolerated by patients withdrawn from study was 397.2 mg per square meter of body-surface area in the FDC group and 466.3 mg in the FDC + ICRF-187 group (no significant difference). Eleven patients on the FDC + ICRF-187 arm received cumulative doxorubicin doses above 600 mg per square meter, whereas one receiving FDC was able to remain in the study beyond this dose. Antitumor response rates were similar (FDC vs. FDC + ICRF-187, 3 vs. 4 complete responses; 17 vs. 17 partial responses; and 9.3 vs. 10.3 months to disease progression). Although myelosuppression was slightly greater in the FDC + ICRF-187 group, the incidence of fever, infections, alopecia, nausea and vomiting, or death due to toxicity did not differ between the groups. Cardiac toxicity was evaluated by clinical examination, determination of the left ventricular ejection fraction by multigated nuclear scans, and endomyocardial biopsy. In comparisons of the FDC group with the FDC + ICRF-187 group, clinical congestive heart failure was observed in 11 as compared with 2 patients; the mean decrease in the left ventricular ejection fraction was 7 vs. 1 percent when the cumulative dose of doxorubicin was 250 to 399 mg per square meter (P = 0.02), 16 vs. 1 percent at 400 to 499 mg (P = 0.001), and 16 vs. 3 percent at 500 to 599 mg (P = 0.003); and the Billingham biopsy score was 2 or more in 5 of 13 patients undergoing biopsy vs. none of 13 (P = 0.03). We conclude that ICRF-187 offers significant protection against cardiac toxicity caused by doxorubicin, without affecting the antitumor effect of doxorubicin or the incidence of noncardiac toxic reactions.
对动物的研究表明,双哌嗪二酮ICRF - 187可预防与剂量相关的阿霉素诱导的心脏毒性的发生。在一项针对92名晚期乳腺癌女性的随机试验中,我们比较了每21天给予氟尿嘧啶、阿霉素和环磷酰胺(FDC)的治疗方案,以及在相同方案之前给予ICRF - 187(FDC + ICRF - 187)的治疗方案。当出现心脏毒性或癌症进展时,患者退出研究。退出研究的患者所耐受的阿霉素平均累积剂量在FDC组为每平方米体表面积397.2毫克,在FDC + ICRF - 187组为466.3毫克(无显著差异)。FDC + ICRF - 187组有11名患者接受的阿霉素累积剂量超过每平方米600毫克,而接受FDC治疗的患者中有1名在超过此剂量后仍能留在研究中。抗肿瘤反应率相似(FDC组与FDC + ICRF - 187组,完全缓解分别为3例对4例;部分缓解分别为17例对17例;疾病进展时间分别为9.3个月对10.3个月)。虽然FDC + ICRF - 187组的骨髓抑制略更严重,但两组间发热、感染、脱发、恶心和呕吐或因毒性导致的死亡发生率并无差异。通过临床检查、用多门控核素扫描测定左心室射血分数以及心内膜活检来评估心脏毒性。在FDC组与FDC + ICRF - 187组的比较中,观察到临床充血性心力衰竭在FDC组有11例,而在FDC + ICRF - 187组有2例;当阿霉素累积剂量为每平方米250至399毫克时,左心室射血分数的平均下降分别为7%对1%(P = 0.02),在400至499毫克时为16%对1%(P = 0.001),在500至599毫克时为16%对3%(P = 0.003);在接受活检的13名患者中,FDC组有5名患者的比林厄姆活检评分达到2分或更高,而FDC + ICRF - 187组的13名患者中无一例达到(P = 0.03)。我们得出结论,ICRF - 187可显著预防阿霉素引起的心脏毒性,而不影响阿霉素的抗肿瘤效果或非心脏毒性反应的发生率。