Crenna E, Sinkko T, Sala S
European Commission, Joint Research Centre (JRC), Via Enrico Fermi 2749, I-21027, Ispra, Italy.
J Clean Prod. 2019 Aug 1;227:378-391. doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.04.054.
Food security and biodiversity conservation are closely interconnected challenges to be addressed to achieve a sustainable food system on a global scale. Due to the complex nature of food production and consumption system, quantifying the impacts of food supply chains on biodiversity is challenging. Life cycle assessment (LCA) allows for systematically addressing environmental impacts along supply chains, representing a reference methodology that can be applied for assessing food systems. In the present study, 32 representative food products of consumption in the European Union (EU) were selected and their environmental impacts calculated through a process-based LCA. The potential contribution of EU food consumption to the current biodiversity decline has been evaluated adopting both midpoint and endpoint indicators. A comparison of the impact drivers was performed. Meat products, the underpinning land use for agricultural purposes, and climate change represent the main hotspots of impacts on biodiversity. Notwithstanding several drivers of biodiversity loss can be accounted for with LCA, the evidence of the increasing biodiversity decline on both a European and a global scale indicates that the assessment system should be further expanded, especially for what concerns refining impact categories such as ecotoxicity, and including resource overexploitation, and impact due to invasive species. This study illustrates: how far the current LCA based impact assessment framework may help to address the drivers of biodiversity loss; which are the main uncertainties associated to results stemming from the application of different endpoint methods; which aspects need to be elaborated further to ensure a comprehensive assessment of biodiversity impacts due to food production and consumption.
粮食安全和生物多样性保护是实现全球可持续粮食系统需要应对的紧密相连的挑战。由于粮食生产和消费系统的复杂性,量化食品供应链对生物多样性的影响具有挑战性。生命周期评估(LCA)能够系统地解决供应链中的环境影响问题,是一种可用于评估粮食系统的参考方法。在本研究中,选取了欧盟32种具有代表性的消费食品,并通过基于过程的生命周期评估计算其环境影响。采用中点和终点指标评估了欧盟食品消费对当前生物多样性下降的潜在贡献。对影响驱动因素进行了比较。肉类产品、农业用地的基础土地利用以及气候变化是对生物多样性影响的主要热点。尽管生命周期评估可以考虑生物多样性丧失的几个驱动因素,但欧洲和全球范围内生物多样性下降加剧的证据表明,评估系统应进一步扩展,特别是在细化生态毒性等影响类别、纳入资源过度开发以及外来物种影响方面。本研究说明了:当前基于生命周期评估的影响评估框架在多大程度上有助于应对生物多样性丧失的驱动因素;应用不同终点方法产生的结果存在哪些主要不确定性;需要进一步阐述哪些方面,以确保全面评估粮食生产和消费对生物多样性的影响。