Kirk David Anthony, Hébert Katherine, Goldsmith Frank Barrie
Department of Geography, University College London, University of London, London, United Kingdom.
Current affiliation: Aquila Conservation & Environment Consulting, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
PeerJ. 2019 Aug 13;7:e7296. doi: 10.7717/peerj.7296. eCollection 2019.
Mediterranean maquis vegetation is highly biodiverse, but widespread grazing poses a challenge for management and conservation. We sampled woody and herbaceous plants separately on a limestone mountain with strong mesic-xeric gradients in Tunisia's Parc National de L'Ichkeul, assessed grazing pressure (on a scale of 1-3), and asked whether grazing had a significant effect on plant compositional abundance before and after controlling for environmental covariates. Sites on the more mesic lakeside face of the mountain were most compositionally unique, and forbs contributed most to the herbaceous beta-diversity on the mountain. We used variance partitioning to separate the collective and individual effects of the abiotic environment, grazing, human activity, and space on herbaceous and woody beta-diversity. However, the individual effect of grazing on overall plant community composition was confounded with space, due to the spatially autocorrelated grazing pressure on the mountain. Importantly, we found that herbaceous and woody communities responded differently to increasing levels of grazing intensity: herbaceous beta-diversity was highest between sites with no grazing pressure, while woody beta-diversity peaked under light grazing. Herbaceous community composition was sensitive to any intensity of grazing pressure, and biotic homogenization occured under moderate-to-high grazing pressure. On the other hand, woody community composition remained relatively similar under no to light grazing pressure, but differed under moderate-to-heavy grazing. Using a one-way permutational analysis of variance analysis, we showed that grazing had a significant effect when controlling for abiotic and spatial covariates. Our findings offer insight into the effects of grazing on maquis vegetation at Jebel Ichkeul, acting as a microcosm of similar conservation and management issues elsewhere in the Mediterranean. We suggest that a combination of monitoring and carefully controlled grazing may enhance plant diversity and maintain the region's biodiverse maquis vegetation, potentially maintaining a key climate refugium for vulnerable endemic species. Importantly, our study provides a useful baseline of the plant assemblages at Jebel Ichkeul with which to compare future vegetation changes.
地中海马基植被具有高度的生物多样性,但广泛的放牧对其管理和保护构成了挑战。我们在突尼斯伊其克乌尔国家公园一座具有强烈中生-旱生梯度的石灰岩山上分别对木本植物和草本植物进行了采样,评估了放牧压力(范围为1-3),并探讨了在控制环境协变量前后,放牧是否对植物组成丰度有显著影响。在山体更湿润的湖边一侧的地点在组成上最为独特,且草本植物对山上草本植物的β多样性贡献最大。我们使用方差分解来分离非生物环境、放牧、人类活动和空间对草本植物和木本植物β多样性的综合和个体影响。然而,由于山上放牧压力存在空间自相关性,放牧对整个植物群落组成的个体影响与空间因素相互混淆。重要的是,我们发现草本植物和木本植物群落对放牧强度增加的反应不同:草本植物的β多样性在没有放牧压力的地点之间最高,而木本植物的β多样性在轻度放牧下达到峰值。草本植物群落组成对任何放牧压力强度都很敏感,在中度至重度放牧压力下会出现生物同质化。另一方面,在无至轻度放牧压力下,木本植物群落组成保持相对相似,但在中度至重度放牧下则有所不同。通过单向置换方差分析,我们表明在控制非生物和空间协变量时,放牧具有显著影响。我们的研究结果为伊其克乌尔山放牧对马基植被的影响提供了见解,该山是地中海其他地区类似保护和管理问题的一个缩影。我们建议,监测和精心控制放牧相结合可能会增加植物多样性并维持该地区生物多样的马基植被,有可能为脆弱的特有物种维持一个关键的气候避难所。重要的是,我们的研究为伊其克乌尔山的植物群落提供了一个有用的基线,以便与未来的植被变化进行比较。