Kawami Noriyuki, Hoshino Shintaro, Hoshikawa Yoshimasa, Takenouchi Nana, Hanada Yuriko, Tanabe Tomohide, Goto Osamu, Kaise Mitsuru, Iwakiri Katsuhiko
Department of Gastroenterology, Nippon Medical School, Graduate School of Medicine.
J Nippon Med Sch. 2020 Jan 10;86(6):322-326. doi: 10.1272/jnms.JNMS.2019_86-608. Epub 2019 Aug 20.
In a previous study that used the Starlet high-resolution manometry system to assess integrated relaxation pressure (IRP) in healthy adults, the predicted cutoff value was about 26 mm Hg. However, some patients with achalasia have an IRP value of <26 mm Hg. This study examined the validity of the Starlet IRP cutoff value in patients with achalasia.
Among 37 patients with achalasia, the percentage of patients with a Starlet IRP value ≥26 mm Hg was calculated. Patients were then classified as IRP-high (IRP ≥26 mm Hg) and IRP-low (IRP <26 mm Hg), and the groups were compared in relation to basal lower esophageal sphincter (LES) pressure, Chicago classification achalasia subtype, and esophagography subtype.
Twenty (54%) of the 37 patients had an IRP of ≥26 mm Hg. Basal LES pressure was significantly higher in the IRP-high group than in the IRP-low group. Chicago classification Type II achalasia was most common in the IRP-high group, whereas Type I was most common in the IRP-low group. No significant difference was noted in the distribution of esophagography subtypes between groups.
It is difficult to determine an IRP cutoff value with Starlet. When diagnosing achalasia with Starlet, comprehensive assessment must consider findings other than IRP values. In addition, IRP was associated with Chicago classification type.
在之前一项使用Starlet高分辨率测压系统评估健康成年人综合松弛压(IRP)的研究中,预测的临界值约为26毫米汞柱。然而,一些贲门失弛缓症患者的IRP值<26毫米汞柱。本研究探讨了Starlet IRP临界值在贲门失弛缓症患者中的有效性。
计算37例贲门失弛缓症患者中Starlet IRP值≥26毫米汞柱的患者百分比。然后将患者分为IRP高组(IRP≥26毫米汞柱)和IRP低组,并比较两组在基础下食管括约肌(LES)压力、芝加哥分类贲门失弛缓症亚型和食管造影亚型方面的差异。
37例患者中有20例(54%)的IRP≥26毫米汞柱。IRP高组的基础LES压力显著高于IRP低组。芝加哥分类II型贲门失弛缓症在IRP高组中最为常见,而I型在IRP低组中最为常见。两组之间食管造影亚型的分布没有显著差异。
用Starlet确定IRP临界值很困难。使用Starlet诊断贲门失弛缓症时,综合评估必须考虑IRP值以外的其他结果。此外,IRP与芝加哥分类类型有关。