Anderson P R, Knibb W R, Oakeshott J G
Department of Population Biology, Research School of Biological Sciences, Australian National University, Canberra.
Genetica. 1987 Nov 30;75(2):81-8. doi: 10.1007/BF00055251.
Previously we have presented evidence of large-scale latitudinal clines in the frequencies of four chromosome inversions and alleles at six enzyme loci in populations of D. melanogaster in Australasia, Asia and North America. Subsequent sampling by others in Japan and western U.S.A. has failed to repeat this observation for the steepest of the clines (alcohol dehydrogenase and the four chromosome inversions). We argue that this failure reflects the few populations and small latitudinal range sampled in these later studies. From extensive sampling over a long latitudinal transect in Australasia we here document Adh and inversion clines which are virtually identical to those originally obtained in different Australian populations four years earlier. We also repeat our observation that the Adh cline is largely independent of the cline in the linked inversion In(2L)t. We therefore retain our original conclusion that these polymorphisms are subject to natural selection. However the new Australasian data do not indicate an association between Adh and maximum rainfall which had been evident in the earlier data for Australasia, Asia and North America. We therefore retract our claim that the selective agent on Adh is related to rainfall.
此前我们已展示了在澳大拉西亚、亚洲和北美的黑腹果蝇种群中,四个染色体倒位的频率以及六个酶位点上等位基因存在大规模纬度渐变群的证据。随后其他研究人员在日本和美国西部进行的采样未能重现最陡峭渐变群(乙醇脱氢酶和四个染色体倒位)的这一观测结果。我们认为,这种未能重现的情况反映出在这些后续研究中所采样的种群数量较少且纬度范围较小。通过在澳大拉西亚沿长纬度断面进行广泛采样,我们在此记录了乙醇脱氢酶和倒位渐变群,它们实际上与四年前在不同澳大利亚种群中最初获得的结果相同。我们还再次观察到乙醇脱氢酶渐变群在很大程度上独立于连锁倒位In(2L)t中的渐变群。因此,我们维持原来的结论,即这些多态性受到自然选择的影响。然而,新的澳大拉西亚数据并未表明乙醇脱氢酶与最大降雨量之间存在关联,而这在澳大拉西亚、亚洲和北美的早期数据中是明显的。因此,我们撤回我们关于乙醇脱氢酶的选择因子与降雨有关的说法。