Cosnes J, Bellanger J, Gendre J P, Le Quintrec Y
Service de Gastroentérologie et de Pathologie digestive post-opératoire, Hôpital Rothschild, Paris.
Ann Gastroenterol Hepatol (Paris). 1988 Oct;24(5):233-40.
The nutritional development with three types of enteral diets during 28 days, was compared in 45 patients with malnutrition presenting an active Crohn's disease. Enteral feeding consisted of a polymeric mixture (Realmentyl) administered in addition to a normal oral diet in 11 patients; the same mixture was administered alone exclusively to 9 patients, and an elemental diet (Vivonex HN) administered exclusively to 25 patients. The total caloric intake reached, in the three groups, the mean values of 60.2, 36.9 and 33.8 kcal/kg of ideal weight/day, respectively. 33 patients also received steroids. At the end of 28 days of enteral diet, the improvement in the weight and the anthropometric measurements (muscle circumference, triceps skinfold) was significantly more marked (gain of 6.5 kg) with the supplemental polymeric mixture than with exclusive enteral diet, polymeric diet (+/- 2.0 kg) or basic (+1.2 kg). Transferrin and albumin plasma levels increased in all 3 groups, but much faster with the exclusive elemental feeding, in spite of a higher urinary urea excretion in these patients. The overall nutritional development was significantly better with supplemental polymeric feeding, and was identical in the two other groups. These results confirm that the supplemental polymeric enteral feeding is more effective, from the nutrition standpoint. With an exclusive enteral feeding, the nutritional result is appreciably the same, whether the mixture consists of polymers or basic elements.
对45例患有活动性克罗恩病的营养不良患者在28天内使用三种肠内饮食的营养发展情况进行了比较。肠内喂养包括:11例患者在正常口服饮食基础上额外给予聚合混合物(瑞尔美汀);9例患者仅单独给予相同的混合物;25例患者仅给予要素饮食(维沃力克斯HN)。三组的总热量摄入分别达到理想体重/天60.2、36.9和33.8千卡/千克的平均值。33例患者还接受了类固醇治疗。在肠内饮食28天结束时,补充聚合混合物组在体重和人体测量指标(肌肉周长、肱三头肌皮褶厚度)方面的改善明显更显著(体重增加6.5千克),优于单纯肠内饮食组,聚合饮食组(±2.0千克)或基础饮食组(+1.2千克)。所有三组的转铁蛋白和血浆白蛋白水平均升高,但单纯要素喂养组升高得更快,尽管这些患者的尿尿素排泄量更高。补充聚合喂养的总体营养发展明显更好,另外两组相同。这些结果证实,从营养角度来看,补充聚合肠内喂养更有效。对于单纯肠内喂养,无论混合物是由聚合物还是基本元素组成,营养结果大致相同。