Wong Matthew D, Chung Hinfan, Chawla Jasneek
Department of Paediatric Respiratory and Sleep Medicine, Queensland Children's Hospital, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.
School of Medicine, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.
J Paediatr Child Health. 2020 Feb;56(2):309-316. doi: 10.1111/jpc.14606. Epub 2019 Aug 29.
The aims of this study are: (i) to survey the knowledge of paediatric clinicians using overnight continuous pulse oximetry data to guide management of infants with chronic neonatal lung disease (CNLD); (ii) to assess the ability of paediatric clinicians to interpret overnight continuous pulse oximetry data; and (iii) to describe the overnight oximetry interpretation practices of paediatric respiratory specialists.
Paediatric clinicians from three tertiary teaching hospitals completed an anonymous survey regarding overnight continuous pulse oximetry in chronic neonatal lung disease. Using a modified Delphi technique, paediatric respiratory specialists participated in a concordance exercise and discussions to establish consensus interpretations for 25 oximetry studies. Paediatric clinicians were invited to complete the same exercise as a comparison.
Self-rated knowledge from 74 surveyed clinicians was proportional to clinical experience. Twenty paediatric clinicians and nine paediatric respiratory specialists completed the oximetry exercise with scores of 64% (κ = 0.25) and 80% (κ = 0.45), respectively. Individual parameters like a mean peripheral arterial haemoglobin saturation (SpO ) below 93% and percentage time spent below SpO 93% correlated poorly with the consensus interpretations. Paediatric respiratory specialists instead relied on visual analysis of SpO waveforms, utilising the frequency and depth of desaturations to guide management.
Interpretation of overnight oximetry data is variable amongst both paediatric clinicians and respiratory specialists. This likely reflects inadequate evidence defining clinically significant intermittent hypoxaemia, whether in terms of desaturation duration, frequency or nadir.
本研究的目的是:(i)调查儿科临床医生利用夜间连续脉搏血氧饱和度数据指导慢性新生儿肺病(CNLD)婴儿管理的知识;(ii)评估儿科临床医生解读夜间连续脉搏血氧饱和度数据的能力;(iii)描述儿科呼吸专科医生的夜间血氧饱和度解读实践。
来自三家三级教学医院的儿科临床医生完成了一项关于慢性新生儿肺病夜间连续脉搏血氧饱和度的匿名调查。采用改良的德尔菲技术,儿科呼吸专科医生参与了一项一致性练习和讨论,以建立25项血氧饱和度研究的共识解读。邀请儿科临床医生完成相同的练习作为比较。
74名接受调查的临床医生的自评知识与临床经验成正比。20名儿科临床医生和9名儿科呼吸专科医生完成了血氧饱和度练习,得分分别为64%(κ = 0.25)和80%(κ = 0.45)。平均外周动脉血红蛋白饱和度(SpO)低于93%以及SpO低于93%的时间百分比等个体参数与共识解读的相关性较差。相反,儿科呼吸专科医生依靠对SpO波形的视觉分析,利用血氧饱和度降低的频率和深度来指导管理。
儿科临床医生和呼吸专科医生对夜间血氧饱和度数据的解读存在差异。这可能反映出在定义具有临床意义的间歇性低氧血症方面,无论是在血氧饱和度降低持续时间、频率还是最低点方面,证据都不充分。