McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research, Department of Archaeology, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, Pembroke Street, CB2 3ER, UK.
Department of Anthropology, Pennsylvania State University, 322 Carpenter Building, State College, PA, USA.
J Hum Evol. 2019 Oct;135:102654. doi: 10.1016/j.jhevol.2019.102654. Epub 2019 Aug 26.
The human foot is highly derived relative to that of other hominoids and therefore a topic of intense research in paleoanthropology. While trabecular bone is thought to be highly plastic in response to habitual behavior, knowledge of how trabecular structure scale with body size is essential for making functional inferences from trabecular bone morphology. Trabecular bone properties scale with negative allometry in interspecific studies that includes a wide range of body size; however, intraspecific scaling patterns often differ from interspecific trends. In this paper we examine patterns of trabecular bone scaling in the calcaneus, talus, and first metatarsal of four human populations with different subsistence strategies and associated levels of terrestrial mobility. We report Bayesian linear regressions between the natural logarithms of femoral head diameter and five standard trabecular variables calculated in five spherical volumes of interest. We additionally report regressions on population-specific z-scores of femoral head diameter and trabecular variables as a way of placing the four populations on a common scale. Results show that with increasing body size there is no change in bone volume fraction (BV/TV) and trabecular thickness (Tb.Th), a slight increase in trabecular spacing (Tb.Sp), and a sharp decrease in connectivity density (Conn.D). Degree of anisotropy was found to scale with positive allometry in the calcaneus, negative allometry in the talar trochlea, and shows no relationship with femoral head diameter in the talar and first metatarsal heads. These results show that scaling of the degree of anisotropy can vary substantially within and between bones. Degree of anisotropy is often used as a proxy for directionality in joint loading when interpreting variation in trabecular structures of fossils and extant primates. Body size should therefore be an important consideration when trabecular bone structure is used to interpret function from fossil morphology.
人类的足部与其他原始人类相比高度特化,因此成为古人类学研究的热点。虽然小梁骨被认为对外界习惯性活动有很强的适应性,但了解小梁结构如何与体型大小相关对于从小梁骨形态推断功能至关重要。在包括广泛体型范围的种间研究中,小梁骨特性与负异速生长相关;然而,种内的比例模式通常与种间趋势不同。本文中,我们研究了四个具有不同生存策略和相关陆地活动水平的人类群体的跟骨、距骨和第一跖骨的小梁骨比例模式。我们报告了股骨头上直径的自然对数与五个标准小梁变量之间的贝叶斯线性回归,这些变量是在五个感兴趣的球体体积中计算得出的。我们还报告了股骨头上直径和小梁变量的人口特定 z 分数的回归,以此将四个群体置于共同的比例尺度上。结果表明,随着体型的增大,骨体积分数(BV/TV)和小梁厚度(Tb.Th)不变,小梁间距(Tb.Sp)略有增加,连接密度(Conn.D)急剧下降。在跟骨中发现各向异性程度与正异速生长相关,在距骨滑车中与负异速生长相关,在距骨和第一跖骨中与股骨头直径无关。这些结果表明,各向异性程度的比例在骨骼内和骨骼间可以有很大的变化。各向异性程度通常被用作解释化石和现生灵长类动物小梁结构变异时关节负荷方向的替代指标。因此,当从小梁骨形态推断功能时,体型大小应该是一个重要的考虑因素。