CNRS, Aix-Marseille Université, LNC UMR 7291, Marseille, France.
CNRS, Aix-Marseille Université, LNC UMR 7291, Marseille, France.
Cortex. 2019 Nov;120:443-456. doi: 10.1016/j.cortex.2019.07.007. Epub 2019 Jul 27.
In experimental settings, most overt behavioral errors are consciously perceived. They are, however, only the tip of the iceberg, and electromyographic recording of the muscles involved in the response reveals subthreshold incorrect response activations. Although they are all efficiently corrected, such "partial errors" are poorly consciously detected. Electroencephalographic recordings (CSD estimate), revealed the sequence of cortical activities that lead, or not, to conscious detection. Besides medio-prefrontal activities related to action monitoring and error detection, the motor command sent by the primary motor cortices also differed between detected and undetected partial errors: while it develops identically, it is stopped earlier for the latter than for the former, suggesting a critical role in partial error detection. Second, the analysis of the "Error positivity" - Pe, classically linked to error awareness, confirmed its absence just after partial errors, be they detected or not. However, a Pe occurs after the corrective response of partial errors that were detected, suggesting that we become aware of our partial errors only after their correction. The implication of these results for the link between consciousness and cognitive control are discussed.
在实验环境中,大多数明显的行为错误都能被有意识地察觉。然而,这些错误只是冰山一角,涉及反应的肌肉的肌电图记录揭示了阈下的错误反应激活。尽管这些错误都能被有效地纠正,但这种“部分错误”很难被有意识地察觉。脑电图记录(CSD 估计)揭示了导致或不导致意识检测的皮质活动序列。除了与动作监测和错误检测相关的中前额叶活动外,初级运动皮质发出的运动指令在被检测和未被检测到的部分错误之间也有所不同:虽然它们的发展是相同的,但对于后者,它比前者更早地停止,这表明它在部分错误检测中起着关键作用。其次,对“错误正波”(Pe)的分析——经典地与错误意识相关联——证实了它在部分错误之后的缺失,无论它们是否被检测到。然而,在被检测到的部分错误的纠正反应之后会出现 Pe,这表明我们只有在纠正错误后才会意识到自己的部分错误。这些结果对于意识和认知控制之间的联系的意义正在讨论中。