Department of Psychiatry, Griffin Memorial Hospital, Norman, OK, USA.
Department of Psychiatry, Allegheny Health Network, Pittsburgh, PA, USA.
Brain Stimul. 2020 Jan-Feb;13(1):15-19. doi: 10.1016/j.brs.2019.08.012. Epub 2019 Aug 22.
Lithium is a helpful adjunct to patients undergoing ECT. However, only case reports and limited data suggest increase risk of delirium. Thus, this continues to be a controversial issue.
In this study, we examine 1) The association and odds of delirium and cognitive problems with ECT and lithium (ECT + Li) combination compared to ECT alone, 2) If positively associated, would this association vary by both type of mood episode and type of disorder?
A national sample of 64,728 adult psychiatric inpatients across the US (identified from a total data of about 70 million total discharges annually) was analyzed using linear-by-linear association and logistic regression to assess the odds ratio (OR) for delirium and cognitive impairment for those treated with lithium (N = 158), ECT (N = 64148), or ECT + Li (N = 422) after adjusting for demographics and psychiatric diagnoses.
The prevalence of delirium was higher in the ECT + Lithium group (5.7%) vs. ECT only (0.6%) or lithium only groups (0%). Patients managed with ECT + Lithium have 11.7-fold higher odds (95% CI 7.55-17.99, P < 0.001) of delirium compared to ECT alone. In the ECT + Li group, delirium prevalence was 7.8% in unipolar depression, 3.4% in bipolar depressed, 0% in bipolar mania.
These results are surprising given the fading concern about delirium association with ECT + lithium combination. The high odds in the combination group warrant clinical caution, use of lower lithium doses (if combinations cannot be avoided), and vigilance regarding early signs of delirium. These results warrant replication in future studies.
锂对于接受电休克治疗(ECT)的患者有帮助。然而,只有病例报告和有限的数据表明锂会增加谵妄的风险。因此,这仍然是一个有争议的问题。
在这项研究中,我们检验了 1)与单独接受 ECT 相比,ECT 联合锂(ECT+Li)治疗与谵妄和认知问题的关联和比值比(OR),2)如果存在关联,这种关联是否因心境发作的类型和障碍的类型而异?
我们分析了美国全国范围内的 64728 名成年精神科住院患者的样本(从每年约 7000 万总出院人数的总数据中确定),使用线性-线性关联和逻辑回归来评估锂治疗(N=158)、ECT(N=64148)或 ECT+Li(N=422)治疗的患者发生谵妄和认知障碍的 OR,同时调整了人口统计学和精神诊断因素。
ECT+Li 组(5.7%)的谵妄发生率高于单独 ECT 组(0.6%)或单独锂组(0%)。接受 ECT+Li 治疗的患者发生谵妄的可能性是单独接受 ECT 治疗的患者的 11.7 倍(95%CI 7.55-17.99,P<0.001)。在 ECT+Li 组中,单相抑郁患者的谵妄发生率为 7.8%,双相抑郁患者为 3.4%,双相躁狂患者为 0%。
鉴于人们对 ECT+锂联合治疗与谵妄关联的担忧已经减弱,这些结果令人惊讶。联合组的高 OR 值需要临床谨慎,使用较低的锂剂量(如果无法避免联合治疗),并警惕谵妄的早期迹象。这些结果需要在未来的研究中复制。