Center for Women's Reproductive Health, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, Alabama.
Prenat Diagn. 2019 Nov;39(12):1148-1154. doi: 10.1002/pd.5557. Epub 2019 Sep 13.
Evaluate fetal echocardiography's ability to detect critical (lesions requiring immediate neonatal intensive care) congenital heart disease (CHD) after normal anatomic cardiac views on detailed ultrasound.
Singletons with both a detailed ultrasound at 18 + 0 to 22 + 6 weeks and echocardiogram performed at least 14 days later and at 20 + 0 to 24 + 6 weeks. Cases with cardiac pathology on detailed ultrasound were excluded. Different combinations of cardiac views were described: Basic (four-chamber, outflow tracts), Expanded (plus three-vessel view), and Complete (plus ductal/aortic arches). "Normal" was defined on either 2D gray scale or color Doppler. Primary outcome was rates of critical CHD missed on ultrasound but seen on fetal echocardiogram.
One thousand two hundred twenty-three women had normal Basic cardiac views. One thousand one hundred ninety (97.3%) were confirmed normal on echocardiogram. Twenty-one (1.71%) total CHDs were missed, and three were critical (0.25%; 95% CI, 0.03%-0.53%). Of the 1,223 women, 763 had Complete views. Ten (1.31%) total CHDs were missed and one (0.13%; 95% CI, 0.13%-0.36%) was confirmed critical.
Fetal echocardiography can increase CHD detection despite normal cardiac anatomy on detailed ultrasound; however, CHDs missed are rarely critical. Approximately 750 fetal echocardiograms need to be performed to detect one critical CHD with Complete normal cardiac views on detailed ultrasound.
评估详细超声检查后正常心脏解剖结构下胎儿超声心动图检测严重(需要立即新生儿重症监护的病变)先天性心脏病(CHD)的能力。
对 18+0 至 22+6 周进行详细超声检查且至少在 14 天后和 20+0 至 24+6 周进行超声心动图检查的单胎妊娠。排除详细超声检查有心脏病理学的病例。描述了不同的心脏视图组合:基础(四腔心、流出道)、扩展(加三血管视图)和完整(加导管/主动脉弓)。2D 灰度或彩色多普勒均定义为“正常”。主要结局是超声漏诊但胎儿超声心动图可见的严重 CHD 发生率。
1223 名女性的基础心脏视图正常。1199 名(97.3%)在超声心动图上被证实正常。总共漏诊了 21 例(1.71%)CHD,其中 3 例为严重(0.25%;95%CI,0.03%-0.53%)。在 1223 名女性中,763 名有完整视图。总共漏诊了 10 例(1.31%)CHD,其中 1 例(0.13%;95%CI,0.13%-0.36%)为严重。
尽管详细超声检查显示正常心脏解剖结构,但胎儿超声心动图仍可增加 CHD 的检出率;然而,漏诊的 CHD 很少是严重的。在详细超声检查有完整正常心脏视图的情况下,需要进行大约 750 次胎儿超声心动图才能检测到 1 例严重的 CHD。