Effect of chordwise wing flexibility on flapping flight of a butterfly model using immersed-boundary lattice Boltzmann simulations.

Wing flexibility is one of the important factors not only for lift and thrust generation and enhancement in flapping flight but also for development of micro-air vehicles with flapping wings. In this study, we construct a flexible wing with chordwise flexibility by connecting two rigid plates with a torsion spring, and investigate the effect of chordwise wing flexibility on the flapping flight of a simple butterfly model by using an immersed boundary-lattice Boltzmann method. First, we investigate the effects of the spring stiffness on the aerodynamic performance when the body of the model is fixed. We find that the time-averaged lift and thrust forces and the required power increase with the spring stiffness. In addition, we find an appropriate range of the spring stiffness where the time-averaged lift and thrust forces are larger than those of the rigid wings. The mechanism of the lift and thrust enhancements is as follows: in the downstroke the flexible wings can generate not only the lift force but also the thrust force due to the deformation of wings; in the upstroke the flexible wings can generate not only the thrust force but also the lift force due to the deformation of wings. Second, we simulate free flights when the body of the model can only move translationally. We find that the model with the flexible wings at an appropriate value of the spring stiffness can fly more effectively than the model with the rigid wings, which is consistent with the results when the body of the model is fixed. Finally, we simulate free flights with pitching rotation. We find that the model gets off balance for any value of the spring stiffness. Therefore, the passive control of the pitching motion by the chordwise wing flexibility cannot be expected for the present butterfly model.