Department of Food Science and Nutrition, Soonchunhyang University, Asan, Chungcheongnam-do, Republic of Korea.
Department of Food and Nutrition, Seoul National University, 1 Gwanak-ro, Gwanak-gu, Seoul 08826, Republic of Korea.
Public Health Nutr. 2020 Mar;23(4):711-720. doi: 10.1017/S1368980019002544. Epub 2019 Sep 20.
The present study analysed and compared the nutritional qualities of private brand (PB) and national brand (NB) ready meal (RM) products in South Korea.
Data on RM products were collected via a food information database (EatSight) between February and May of 2017. A total of ninety-one PB products from a leading discount store chain in South Korea and 415 NB products were selected and divided into four main categories of 'refrigerated soups/stews', 'refrigerated noodles', 'frozen rice/noodles' and 'frozen dumplings'. Nutritional information was extracted for each product and analyses were performed to compare nutritional differences.
South Korea.
A total of 506 RM products.
PB products explained the highest percentage of refrigerated RM products while NB products occupied the highest percentage of frozen ones. Notably, main PB and NB products showed evident nutritional problems. Among PB products, refrigerated soups/stews were significantly higher in energy, fat, Na, saturated fat and trans-fat. Likewise, in the case of NB products, frozen rice/noodles were significantly higher in Na and saturated fat. Particularly, overall Na contents were high. When the Korean guidance on traffic-light labelling was applied, a mere 0·2 and 5·9 % of total RM products showed all four and three green lights, respectively. Meanwhile, those with no green lights accounted for 42·3 %.
Although it is difficult to draw a definitive conclusion on the comparative nutritional qualities due to the lack of consistency in the results, the study suggests that there is room to improve the nutritional qualities of overall RM products.
本研究分析和比较了韩国自有品牌(PB)和全国品牌(NB)即食产品(RM)的营养质量。
2017 年 2 月至 5 月期间,通过食品信息数据库(EatSight)收集 RM 产品数据。从韩国一家领先的折扣店连锁店中选择了 91 种 PB 产品和 415 种 NB 产品,并将其分为“冷藏汤/炖菜”、“冷藏面条”、“冷冻米饭/面条”和“冷冻饺子”四大类。提取每个产品的营养信息,并进行分析以比较营养差异。
韩国。
共 506 种 RM 产品。
PB 产品解释了冷藏 RM 产品的最高比例,而 NB 产品则占据了冷冻 RM 产品的最高比例。值得注意的是,主要的 PB 和 NB 产品表现出明显的营养问题。在 PB 产品中,冷藏汤/炖菜的能量、脂肪、Na、饱和脂肪和反式脂肪含量明显较高。同样,在 NB 产品中,冷冻米饭/面条的 Na 和饱和脂肪含量明显较高。特别是,总体 Na 含量较高。当应用韩国红绿灯标签指南时,只有 0.2%和 5.9%的 RM 产品总显示全部四个和三个绿灯,而没有绿灯的产品则占 42.3%。
由于结果缺乏一致性,因此很难对比较营养质量得出明确结论,但研究表明,总体 RM 产品的营养质量还有改进的空间。