Maas Joyce, van Balkom Ton, van Assen Marcel, Rutten Liesbeth, Janssen Daniella, van Mastrigt Marietta, Bekker Marrie
Department of Medical and Clinical Psychology, Tilburg University, Tilburg, Netherlands.
Department of Psychiatry GGZ inGeest, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Front Psychiatry. 2019 Sep 12;10:665. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2019.00665. eCollection 2019.
Autonomy-enhancing treatment (AET) is a person-centered, gender-sensitive treatment, targeting transdiagnostic personal autonomy deficits. The current study was set up as a first pilot randomized controlled trial (RCT) to investigate the preliminary efficacy of AET. Earlier small non-controlled plots showed AET to be feasible and acceptable. In the current study (Trial Code 3513), patients receiving 15-session group-based AET ( = 43) were compared with those in a waitlist control condition ( = 40). Both the intention-to-treat and completers analyses suggested a larger decrease in agoraphobic symptoms in the experimental treatment than in the waitlist condition. In both analyses, effect sizes were small. The completers analyses showed additional beneficial effects in two of three autonomy-connectedness components, as well as psychoneuroticism, anxiety, and depression, which disappeared after correcting for multiple testing. AET may alleviate agoraphobic symptoms in a patient sample with severe anxiety. Future research, including more stringent inclusion criteria and follow-up assessment, is needed to further evaluate whether AET may serve as a promising alternative or addition to existing approaches. www.trialregister.nl, identifier NTR3513.
增强自主性治疗(AET)是一种以患者为中心、对性别敏感的治疗方法,针对跨诊断的个人自主性缺陷。本研究作为首个试点随机对照试验(RCT)开展,旨在探究AET的初步疗效。早期的小型非对照试验表明AET是可行且可接受的。在本研究(试验代码3513)中,将接受15节基于小组的AET治疗的患者(n = 43)与处于候补名单对照状态的患者(n = 40)进行比较。意向性分析和完成者分析均表明,与候补名单状态相比,实验性治疗中广场恐怖症症状的减轻幅度更大。在两项分析中,效应量均较小。完成者分析显示,在三个自主性关联成分中的两个成分以及精神质、焦虑和抑郁方面有额外的有益效果,但在进行多重检验校正后这些效果消失了。AET可能会减轻重度焦虑患者样本中的广场恐怖症症状。需要开展包括更严格纳入标准和随访评估在内的未来研究,以进一步评估AET是否可作为现有方法的一种有前景的替代方法或补充方法。www.trialregister.nl,标识符NTR3513。