Navaratnam Ragavan, Davis Tessa
Registrar in Paediatric Emergency Medicine, The Royal London Hospital.
Department of Paedaitric Emergency Medicine, The Royal London Hospital, London, United Kingdom.
J Craniofac Surg. 2019 Oct;30(7):2099-2101. doi: 10.1097/SCS.0000000000005994.
Nasal fractures are the most commonly encountered facial fracture in children presenting to emergency departments. Though plain radiographs have long been used to aid the diagnosis of fractures, its limited diagnostic accuracy has led to the increasing use of ultrasound. Ultrasound offers a cheap, safe, and readily available imaging modality. Evidence in the adult population has shown ultrasound to be far more accurate in identifying nasal fractures. The efficacy of ultrasound in the pediatric setting though remains uncertain.
A systematic review of the Pubmed and EmBase databases was undertaken. The search terms (nose OR nasal) AND (fracture) AND (ultrasound OR ultrasonography OR sonography) and associated MeSH terms were searched. The search was limited to those <18 years of age.
Following review and exclusion, 3 papers met the inclusion criteria. All 3 studies showed ultrasound was able to detect nasal fractures in children. Two studies showed that ultrasound diagnosed fractures with a greater accuracy than plain radiographs. One study used ultrasound alone and reported a sensitivity of 75% and specificity as 92.3%.
With the limited evidence to date in the pediatric population, ultrasound appears to offer a more accurate radiological investigation in nasal fractures. It could be considered diagnostically superior to plain radiographs and reduces radiation exposure in children. Further work is required to better determine its true utility and improve its diagnostic accuracy.
鼻骨骨折是急诊就诊儿童中最常见的面部骨折。尽管X线平片长期以来一直用于辅助骨折诊断,但其有限的诊断准确性导致超声的使用日益增加。超声提供了一种廉价、安全且易于获得的成像方式。成人人群的证据表明,超声在识别鼻骨骨折方面要准确得多。然而,超声在儿科环境中的有效性仍不确定。
对PubMed和EmBase数据库进行了系统评价。检索了检索词(鼻子或鼻)和(骨折)和(超声或超声检查或超声成像)以及相关的医学主题词。检索限于18岁以下的人群。
经过审查和排除,3篇论文符合纳入标准。所有3项研究均表明超声能够检测儿童鼻骨骨折。两项研究表明,超声诊断骨折的准确性高于X线平片。一项研究单独使用超声,报告敏感性为75%,特异性为92.3%。
鉴于目前儿科人群的证据有限,超声似乎在鼻骨骨折的放射学检查中提供了更准确的结果。它在诊断上可被认为优于X线平片,并减少了儿童的辐射暴露。需要进一步开展工作以更好地确定其真正效用并提高其诊断准确性。