McGuinness Myra B, Finger Robert P, Wu Zhichao, Luu Chi D, Chen Fred K, Arnold Jenifer J, Chakravarthy Usha, Heriot Wilson J, Runciman Jim, Guymer Robyn H
Centre for Eye Research Australia, East Melbourne, Australia.
Department of Ophthalmology, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany.
Transl Vis Sci Technol. 2019 Sep 11;8(5):3. doi: 10.1167/tvst.8.5.3. eCollection 2019 Sep.
To explore the psychometric properties of the Impact of Vision Impairment (IVI-28) and Night Vision Questionnaires (NVQ-10) among people with intermediate age-related macular degeneration (iAMD).
Baseline responses were collected from 288 participants (aged 50-88 years, 74% female) in the Laser intervention in Early stages of Age-related macular Degeneration (LEAD) study in Australia and Northern Ireland. Psychometric properties (discrimination, ordering of thresholds, person separation, item miss-fit, and differential item functioning according to sex) were explored using grouped rating scale and partial credit models. Spearman's correlation was estimated to assess the association with measures of visual function (mean mesopic microperimetric sensitivity, best-corrected visual acuity, low-luminance visual acuity, and low-luminance deficit). The psychometric properties were then explored following recalibration of the instruments.
In this homogenous population, ceiling effects caused by relatively high levels of functional vision were evident for both instruments. The IVI-28 and NVQ-10 displayed suboptimal discrimination between levels of functional vision in iAMD and poor targeting among people with iAMD. The correlation between ability scores and measures of visual function was mild. In general, the NVQ-10 showed superior psychometric properties to the IVI-28 among these participants. No significant improvement in reliability could be gained following recalibration.
Both instruments were designed for populations with more severe visual loss and poorly discriminate in this cohort of iAMD.
New instruments that can capture the subtle changes in functional vision that occur early in AMD are required to aid evaluation of emerging interventions for iAMD.
探讨视力损害影响问卷(IVI - 28)和夜视问卷(NVQ - 10)在中度年龄相关性黄斑变性(iAMD)患者中的心理测量特性。
从澳大利亚和北爱尔兰的年龄相关性黄斑变性早期激光干预(LEAD)研究中的288名参与者(年龄50 - 88岁,74%为女性)收集基线反应。使用分组评分量表和部分计分模型探索心理测量特性(区分度、阈值排序、人员区分度、项目不匹配以及按性别区分的项目功能差异)。估计Spearman相关性以评估与视觉功能测量指标(平均中视微视野敏感度、最佳矫正视力、低亮度视力和低亮度缺陷)的关联。然后在重新校准工具后探索心理测量特性。
在这个同质人群中,两种工具都明显存在由相对较高水平的功能性视力导致的天花板效应。IVI - 28和NVQ - 10在iAMD患者的功能性视力水平之间显示出次优的区分度,并且在iAMD患者中针对性较差。能力得分与视觉功能测量指标之间的相关性较弱。总体而言,在这些参与者中,NVQ - 10显示出比IVI - 28更好的心理测量特性。重新校准后可靠性没有显著提高。
这两种工具都是为视力丧失更严重的人群设计的,在这个iAMD队列中区分度不佳。
需要能够捕捉AMD早期发生的功能性视力细微变化的新工具,以帮助评估针对iAMD的新兴干预措施。