Cardoso Fernandes L C, de Araújo Oliveira J, Rabello P M, Santiago B M, Diniz de Carvalho M V, Soriano E P
Department of Social Dentistry, Division of Forensic Dentistry, University of Campinas, Piracicaba São Paulo, Brazil.
Department of Clinical and Social Dentistry, Federal University of Paraíba, Univesity city, João Pessoa, Paraíba, Brazil.
J Forensic Odontostomatol. 2019 Sep 30;37(2):9-17.
The study aimed to carry out a comparative analysis between the lip print patterns in individuals with Down Syndrome and their nonsyndromic biological siblings. This was a cross-sectional blind study using an inductive approach and extensive direct observation procedures. A total of 68 cheiloscopic charts, named cheilograms, were divided into two groups (n=34), as follows: G1, including Down Syndrome individuals; and G2, including their nonsyndromic siblinggs. The convenience sample was selected in the city of João Pessoa, PB, Brazil. The following features were evaluated in eight labial regions called sub-quadrants: oral commissures (downturned, horizontal and upturned); lip thickness (thin, medium, thick and mixed); and labial grooves (I - complete vertical; I '- incomplete vertical; II - bifurcated; III - criss-cross; IV - reticular; or V - undefined). The data were analyzed by paired Student's t test and McNemar's Chi-square, with a 5% significance level. Most Down Syndrome individuals were found to have downturned oral commissures in 73.5% of cases, while their siblings showed a predominance of horizontal commissures in 73.5% of cases (p=0.009). There was no statistically significant difference for lip thickness between groups. In the analysis of labial groove patterns, Down Syndrome individuals (G1) showed a significant prevalence of the type I pattern (52.2%) as compared to their nonsyndromic siblings (30.1%) (p =< 0.001). Due to the tendency of having vertical labial groove patterns and downturned commissures, Down Syndrome individuals present cheiloscopic differences in relation to their nonsyndromic biological siblings, which suggests that syndromic genetics influences the development of these features. However, this may imply in a reduced potential of cheiloscopic identification due to the low divergence of labial phenotypes among Down Syndrome individuals.
该研究旨在对唐氏综合征患者及其非综合征生物学同胞的唇纹模式进行比较分析。这是一项采用归纳法和广泛直接观察程序的横断面盲法研究。总共68张唇纹图谱,称为唇纹ogram,分为两组(n = 34),如下:G1组,包括唐氏综合征患者;G2组,包括他们的非综合征同胞。便利样本是在巴西帕拉伊巴州若昂佩索阿市选取的。在八个称为亚象限的唇部区域评估了以下特征:口角(向下、水平和向上);唇厚度(薄、中、厚和混合);以及唇沟(I - 完全垂直;I' - 不完全垂直;II - 分叉;III - 交叉;IV - 网状;或V - 不明确)。数据采用配对学生t检验和麦克尼马尔卡方检验进行分析,显著性水平为5%。结果发现,大多数唐氏综合征患者口角向下的比例为73.5%,而他们的同胞中口角水平的比例占73.5%(p = 0.009)。两组之间唇厚度没有统计学上的显著差异。在唇沟模式分析中,唐氏综合征患者(G1组)I型模式的患病率显著高于他们的非综合征同胞(30.1%)(52.2%)(p <= 0.001)。由于唐氏综合征患者有垂直唇沟模式和口角向下的倾向,与他们的非综合征生物学同胞相比,他们存在唇纹差异,这表明综合征遗传学影响了这些特征的发育。然而,这可能意味着由于唐氏综合征患者唇表型差异较小,唇纹识别的潜力降低。