Pinchi V, Vitale G, Pradella F, Farese L, Focardi M
Section of Forensic Medical Sciences, University of Florence, Italy.
J Forensic Odontostomatol. 2018 May 30;36(1):44-52.
When the age of an individual is unknown, age assessment refers to the procedures through which authorities try to establish the chronological age of an individual. Dental evidence demonstrated to be very effective in estimating age and dental mineralization is largely deemed a process scarcely influenced by major diseases and nutritional or environmental factors which can affect child growth. This research aims to understand the possible influence of genetic syndromes on dental maturation of affected individuals. The sample is composed of a test sample of 159 chromosomal affected children, 69 males and 90 females, and a control sample of 157 healthy children, 77 males and 80 females aged between 4,49 and 19,8years. London Atlas was applied to estimate dental age on OPGs (orthopantompographies). No statistical significant difference has been found in dental estimates between syndromic and healthy individuals. Moreover no statistical significant difference emerged between sexes and age cohorts. Children affected by Down or Williams syndromes nor mean error neither the mean accuracy per cohort of age show differences compared to non-affected subjects. The London Atlas can be validly applied to age estimation of individuals with multiple agenesis as in Down and Williams syndromes, even if it a slight overestimation of age occurs systematically in syndromic as well as in healthy samples. The current findings suggest that dental maturation is a very stable biological process scarcely affected by even serious illnesses as genetic syndromes.
当个体年龄未知时,年龄评估是指有关当局试图确定个体实际年龄的程序。牙齿证据在估计年龄方面已被证明非常有效,而且牙齿矿化在很大程度上被认为是一个几乎不受可能影响儿童生长的重大疾病、营养或环境因素影响的过程。本研究旨在了解基因综合征对受影响个体牙齿成熟的可能影响。样本包括159名受染色体影响儿童的测试样本(69名男性和90名女性)以及157名健康儿童的对照样本(77名男性和80名女性),年龄在4.49岁至19.8岁之间。应用《伦敦图谱》根据曲面体层摄影(OPG)来估计牙齿年龄。在患有综合征的个体与健康个体的牙齿估计方面未发现统计学上的显著差异。此外,在性别和年龄组之间也未出现统计学上的显著差异。与未受影响的受试者相比,患有唐氏综合征或威廉姆斯综合征的儿童在每个年龄组的平均误差和平均准确性方面均无差异。《伦敦图谱》可有效地应用于患有多种发育不全(如唐氏综合征和威廉姆斯综合征)个体的年龄估计,即使在患有综合征的样本以及健康样本中都系统性地出现了对年龄的轻微高估。目前的研究结果表明,牙齿成熟是一个非常稳定的生物学过程,即使是像基因综合征这样的严重疾病也几乎不会对其产生影响。