Faculty of Medicine, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Japan.
Med Teach. 2020 Jan;42(1):101-110. doi: 10.1080/0142159X.2019.1665633. Epub 2019 Oct 9.
We examined the interrelationships between context, mechanism, and outcome using a realist approach following the introduction of interprofessional education (IPE) to clinical practice for medical students in the community. Through participant observation and interviews, a working hypothesis was developed. To evaluate IPE in clinical practice, medical students' reports were thematically analyzed, and configuration on contexts, mechanisms, and outcomes were identified using a realist approach. Influential contexts were medical students' experience of clinical practice and learning characteristics, the capacity of other professionals, interprofessional relationships, and characteristics of the community hospital. One key mechanism was observational learning. Others were self-regulated learning, legitimate peripheral participation, experiential learning, contact hypotheses, awareness of social structure, and cognitive empathy. As faculties supported these key mechanisms, medical students became aware of the legitimacy of community-oriented primary care, noting the roles of physicians who support patients' and/or their family's life in collaboration with other professionals, and reflecting the necessity of shifting from physician-centered perspectives. As a result, medical students deepened their empathic understanding for other professionals. Faculties should develop IPE programs in clinical practice based on the 'mechanism', 'context', 'outcome' pattern and 'context-mechanism-outcome' configuration in primary care settings.
我们采用现实主义方法,在向医学生介绍社区临床实践中的跨专业教育(IPE)后,研究了背景、机制和结果之间的相互关系。通过参与观察和访谈,制定了一个工作假设。为了评估临床实践中的 IPE,对医学生的报告进行了主题分析,并使用现实主义方法确定了背景、机制和结果的配置。有影响力的背景包括医学生的临床实践经验和学习特点、其他专业人员的能力、跨专业关系以及社区医院的特点。一个关键机制是观察学习。其他机制包括自我调节学习、合法的边缘参与、体验式学习、接触假设、对社会结构的认识和认知同理心。随着教师支持这些关键机制,医学生开始意识到以社区为导向的初级保健的合法性,注意到支持患者和/或其家人生活的医生的角色,以及与其他专业人员合作的必要性,反映了从以医生为中心的观点转变的必要性。结果,医学生加深了对其他专业人员的同理心理解。教师应根据初级保健环境中的“机制”、“背景”、“结果”模式和“背景-机制-结果”配置,在临床实践中开发 IPE 计划。