Division of Medical Oncology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota.
Division of Biomedical Statistics and Informatics, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota.
Thyroid. 2019 Nov;29(11):1615-1622. doi: 10.1089/thy.2019.0086.
Anaplastic thyroid cancer (ATC) has poor prognosis with median overall survival (OS) of ∼6 months. We previously reported high PD-1/PDL-1 staining in ATC, raising the possibility of the productive application of the immunotherapeutic pembrolizumab. However, having found pembrolizumab to anecdotally have limited single-agent activity in ATC, we sought to alternatively define whether pembrolizumab might synergistically combine with chemoradiotherapy as initial ATC therapy. An investigator-initiated therapeutic phase 2 trial of pembrolizumab, 200 mg intravenously (IV) every 3 weeks, combined with chemoradiotherapy (docetaxel/doxorubicin, 20 mg/m each IV weekly plus volumetric modulated arc therapy) was initiated as frontline therapy (with or without surgery) in ATC to assess efficacy and toxicities. Six-month OS was selected as the primary endpoint using a Simon's optimal design with interim analysis (targeting accrual of 25 patients; Cohort A: prior resection, Cohort B: no resection). Based on a prior patient cohort-treated similarly, but without pembrolizumab, the design was such that, if 6-month true survival is 75%, the probability of declaring the approach worthy of further pursuit would be 91%. Three patients were enrolled, two with rapidly enlarging unresectable neck masses. Early tumor responses were favorable in all three, and all three satisfactorily completed: intended radiotherapy, preceding and radiotherapy-concurrent pembrolizumab, and concurrent chemoradiotherapy. However, all three patients died <6 months following therapy initiation-one from pulmonary metastases and two from otherwise unexpected fatal pulmonary complications occurring subsequent to chemoradiotherapy completion-prompting study closure. Although initially tolerated and effective in terms of locoregional disease control, disappointing survival outcomes compared with historical controls raise uncertainty that the piloted approach merits further pursuit in ATC.
间变性甲状腺癌(ATC)预后差,中位总生存期(OS)约为 6 个月。我们之前报道 ATC 中 PD-1/PDL-1 染色高,这提高了免疫治疗药物 pembrolizumab 可能具有疗效的可能性。然而,我们发现 pembrolizumab 对 ATC 的单药活性有限,因此我们试图确定 pembrolizumab 是否可以与放化疗联合作为初始 ATC 治疗。我们发起了一项 pembrolizumab 联合放化疗(多西他赛/阿霉素,20mg/m 静脉注射每周一次加容积调强弧形治疗)的研究者发起的治疗性 2 期试验,作为 ATC 的一线治疗(有或无手术),以评估疗效和毒性。6 个月 OS 被选为主要终点,采用 Simon 最优设计进行中期分析(目标入组 25 例;A 队列:有手术史,B 队列:无手术史)。基于之前接受类似治疗但未使用 pembrolizumab 的患者队列,该设计是这样的,如果 6 个月的真实生存率为 75%,那么宣布该方法值得进一步探索的概率将为 91%。入组了 3 例患者,其中 2 例患者的颈部不可切除的肿块迅速增大。所有患者的早期肿瘤反应均良好,并且均顺利完成:计划放疗、放疗前和放疗期间的 pembrolizumab 以及同期放化疗。然而,所有 3 例患者在治疗开始后 6 个月内死亡-1 例死于肺转移,2 例死于放疗后意外致命的肺部并发症,导致研究关闭。尽管该方案在局部疾病控制方面最初耐受且有效,但与历史对照相比,令人失望的生存结果增加了该方案在 ATC 中进一步探索的不确定性。