Vakhtin Andrei A, Zhang Yu, Wintermark Max, Massaband Payam, Robinson Miguel T, Ashford John W, Furst Ansgar J
War Related Illness and Injury Study Center, System of Care, Veterans Affairs Palo Alto, Palo Alto, California.
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California.
J Neurotrauma. 2020 Jan 15;37(2):373-381. doi: 10.1089/neu.2019.6487. Epub 2019 Nov 8.
Comparisons of white matter (WM) fractional anisotropy (FA) values between mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) patients and controls have revealed inconsistencies in the directions of the resulting FA changes. To address these discrepancies, we examined hemispheric FA symmetry levels across WM tracts in 150 mTBI patients relative to 96 military controls. Automated fiber quantification was used to extract 18 WM tracts with 100 FA values, which were used to compute correlation strengths between the nine bilateral tract pairs. The Fisher z-transformed Pearson's values were entered into an analysis of covariance examining the effects of group (mTBI and controls) and age on symmetry levels within each tract pair. The mTBI group displayed lower symmetry levels in the corticospinal tract and the inferior longitudinal fasciculus. Interactions between age and group were detected in the inferior fronto-occipital (IFOF), uncinate (UF), and superior longitudinal fasciculi (SLF). A similar pattern emerged in the IFOF and the UF, revealing age-related symmetry decreases in the mTBI patients despite stable levels of symmetry across ages in controls. In contrast, although the control group's symmetry levels actually increased with age in the SLF, no age-related symmetry changes were detected across the mTBI participants. Here, we proposed WM symmetry measures as a potential means of circumventing directional inconsistencies of trauma-related FA changes, as well as capturing more within-tract and within-subject variances of diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) metrics. Further, we demonstrated the method's utility in detecting mTBI-specific effects and their associated interactions with age.
轻度创伤性脑损伤(mTBI)患者与对照组之间白质(WM)分数各向异性(FA)值的比较显示,FA变化方向存在不一致性。为了解决这些差异,我们研究了150例mTBI患者相对于96名军事对照组在整个白质束中的半球FA对称水平。使用自动纤维定量技术提取18条白质束及100个FA值,用于计算9对双侧束之间的相关强度。将Fisher z变换后的Pearson相关值纳入协方差分析,以检验组(mTBI和对照组)和年龄对每对束内对称水平的影响。mTBI组在皮质脊髓束和下纵束中显示出较低的对称水平。在额枕下束(IFOF)、钩束(UF)和上纵束(SLF)中检测到年龄与组之间的相互作用。IFOF和UF中出现了类似的模式,表明mTBI患者中与年龄相关的对称性降低,而对照组中各年龄的对称水平稳定。相比之下,虽然对照组在SLF中的对称水平实际上随年龄增加,但在mTBI参与者中未检测到与年龄相关的对称变化。在此,我们提出白质对称测量作为一种潜在手段,以规避创伤相关FA变化的方向不一致性,并捕捉扩散张量成像(DTI)指标更多的束内和个体内差异。此外,我们证明了该方法在检测mTBI特异性效应及其与年龄的相关相互作用方面的效用。