Department of Forensic Medicine, Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine, Monash University, 65 Kavanagh Street, Southbank, Melbourne, Victoria, 3006, Australia.
Forensic Sci Med Pathol. 2020 Mar;16(1):78-90. doi: 10.1007/s12024-019-00183-6. Epub 2019 Oct 22.
This study standardized the methods used in the determination of orofacial injuries in Victorian family violence homicides and informed potential control selection for an analytic study. Dental service contacts with family violence victims may be intervention avenues due to the presence of abusive injuries in the orofacial region. All Victorian family homicides from January 2000-September 2018 were identified by determining the kinship/relationship and grouped by age. A 20% random sample of adult cases, aged 18-64 years was selected. The median number of orofacial injuries in categories of injury mechanisms/age/gender and the nature of abusive orofacial injuries was reported for the sample. Of 357 closed cases of family homicide, 261 were adults aged 18-64 years. Offender information and injury mechanism data was available for all closed cases, enabling case selection. Of a random sample of 50 adults, 8 cases were excluded. After 2006, CT scans and photos were present in 20 (91%) and 19 (86.4%) of 22 cases, respectively. The nature and median number of orofacial injuries showed correlation to the reported injury mechanism. Strengths and limitations of the used methods were assessed. Not all cases were compatible for assessment of orofacial injuries, thus serving as an additional criterion for exclusion in our methodology. Further detailed study of the whole population of adults should be limited to the period 2006-2018 where the data is more complete. The mechanism of injury may influence control selection for analytic studies. We present preliminary evidence of the frequent occurrence of orofacial injuries in family violence homicides.
本研究规范了维多利亚州家庭暴力杀人案中口腔面部损伤的测定方法,并为分析性研究提供了潜在的对照选择。由于口腔面部区域存在虐待性损伤,因此与家庭暴力受害者有牙科服务接触可能是干预途径。通过确定亲属关系/关系并按年龄分组,确定了 2000 年 1 月至 2018 年 9 月期间所有维多利亚州家庭杀人案。选择了年龄在 18-64 岁之间的成人病例的 20%随机样本。报告了样本中各损伤机制/年龄/性别和口腔损伤性质的口腔损伤类别中的中位数数量。在 357 例已结案的家庭杀人案中,有 261 例为 18-64 岁的成年人。所有已结案的案件均提供了罪犯信息和损伤机制数据,从而能够进行病例选择。在随机抽取的 50 名成年人中,有 8 例被排除在外。2006 年后,CT 扫描和照片分别在 22 例中的 20 例(91%)和 19 例(86.4%)中存在。口腔损伤的性质和中位数数量与报告的损伤机制相关。评估了所用方法的优缺点。并非所有病例都适合评估口腔损伤,因此这是我们方法学中排除的另一个标准。应仅限于数据更完整的 2006-2018 年期间,对所有成年人的整个人口进行更详细的研究。损伤机制可能会影响分析性研究的对照选择。我们初步证明了家庭暴力杀人案中口腔面部损伤的频繁发生。