Tallman Sean D, Blanton Amelia I
Department of Anatomy & Neurobiology, Program in Forensic Anthropology, Boston University School of Medicine, 72 East Concord Street (L 1004), Boston, MA, 02118.
Department of Anthropology, Boston University, 232 Bay State Road #105, Boston, MA, 02215.
J Forensic Sci. 2020 Mar;65(2):361-371. doi: 10.1111/1556-4029.14218. Epub 2019 Oct 23.
Due to differential preservation, it is necessary to develop sex estimation methods on varied anatomical regions, including the distal humerus. Sexually dimorphic differences of the medial epicondyle angle, olecranon fossa shape, trochlear extension, and trochlear constriction have been documented in several non-Asian groups. This study examines distal humerus morphological variation in 616 modern Thai individuals (f = 198; m = 418) 18-96 years old and tests the methods on a hold-out sample of 152 individuals (f = 91; m = 61). The results indicate that population-specific binary probit regression performs the best (74.1-100%), followed by composite scoring (77.0-90.1%), binary logistic regression (63.3-92.2%), and univariate sectioning points (37.7-90.1%). Age minimally effects the expression of the medial epicondyle angle in males, and trait scoring is susceptible to high intra- and interobserver error. While demonstrating relatively high sex biases, distal humerus morphology can be used to estimate the sex of Thai individuals when more sexually dimorphic regions are absent.
由于保存情况存在差异,有必要针对包括肱骨远端在内的不同解剖区域开发性别估计方法。在几个非亚洲群体中,已记录到内上髁角、鹰嘴窝形状、滑车延伸和滑车缩窄的两性差异。本研究调查了616名年龄在18至96岁之间的现代泰国个体(女性=198名;男性=418名)的肱骨远端形态变化,并在152名个体(女性=91名;男性=61名)的预留样本上测试了这些方法。结果表明,特定人群的二元概率回归表现最佳(74.1%-100%),其次是综合评分(77.0%-90.1%)、二元逻辑回归(63.3%-92.2%)和单变量分割点法(37.7%-90.1%)。年龄对男性内上髁角的表达影响最小,特征评分容易受到观察者内部和观察者之间的高误差影响。虽然肱骨远端形态表现出相对较高的性别偏差,但在缺乏更多两性差异明显的区域时,可用于估计泰国个体的性别。