School of Architecture, Department of Design, Architecture and Building, University of Technology, Sydney, Australia.
School of Nursing, Faculty of Health, University of Technology, Sydney, Australia.
PLoS One. 2019 Oct 29;14(10):e0215795. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0215795. eCollection 2019.
In Australia and internationally, domestic violence is a major cause of homelessness for women and children and yet provision for accommodation for this user-group is not well documented or understood. When designing emergency accommodation, the concerns, preferences, and perspectives of individuals who access refuge services must be sought in order to create spaces that are conducive to the needs of this diverse and vulnerable group. An empathic 'lens' can provide meaningful insights that can inform the design of refuge services specifically targeted at addressing these needs. This paper describes an authentic interdisciplinary learning experience for nursing, architecture and landscape students at a university in Sydney, Australia, and presents the results of a study designed to measure the impact of this initiative on participants' empathy towards women and children who access refuge services as a result of homelessness and/or domestic violence. Empathy levels were measured using the Comprehensive State Empathy Scale, a validated measurement tool.
The learning experience consisted of collaborative meetings with stakeholders from the refuge sector, fieldwork, individual research, exchanging ideas and problem-solving in teams. Students then developed design guides for refuges that demonstrated their emerging understanding of the specific needs and perspectives of the issues faced by women and children who had experienced violence and found themselves homeless. Pre-post Comprehensive State Empathy Scale results indicated that the empathy levels of nursing and landscape students increased and those of architecture students decreased, however, these results were not statistically significant.
The significance of the results from this study include an ability to compare the changes in empathy in students working collaboratively on a project and to ascertain possible reasons for this using a validated measurement tool. As empathy is one of the strongest negative correlates of prejudice, authentic teaching and learning activities, such as the one described in this paper, have the potential to positively impact the lived experience of women and children leaving situations of domestic violence.
在澳大利亚和国际上,家庭暴力是导致妇女和儿童无家可归的主要原因,但为这一用户群体提供住宿的服务并没有得到很好的记录或理解。在设计紧急住宿时,必须征求寻求庇护服务的个人的关注、偏好和观点,以便创建有利于这个多样化和脆弱群体需求的空间。富有同情心的“视角”可以提供有意义的见解,为专门针对解决这些需求的难民服务设计提供信息。本文介绍了澳大利亚悉尼一所大学的护理、建筑和景观专业学生的真实跨学科学习体验,并介绍了一项旨在衡量该举措对参与者同理心的影响的研究结果,这些参与者因无家可归和/或家庭暴力而寻求庇护服务。同理心水平使用综合状态同理心量表进行衡量,这是一种经过验证的测量工具。
学习体验包括与难民部门利益相关者的合作会议、实地考察、个人研究、团队内交流想法和解决问题。然后,学生们为避难所制定了设计指南,展示了他们对经历过暴力和无家可归的妇女和儿童所面临问题的具体需求和观点的理解。综合状态同理心量表的前后测结果表明,护理和景观专业学生的同理心水平有所提高,而建筑专业学生的同理心水平有所下降,但这些结果没有统计学意义。
这项研究的结果意义在于能够比较在一个项目上合作的学生的同理心变化,并使用经过验证的测量工具确定可能的原因。由于同理心是偏见的最强负相关因素之一,因此,如本文所述的真实教学和学习活动有可能对离开家庭暴力处境的妇女和儿童的生活经历产生积极影响。