Epstein Richard H, Dexter Franklin, Cajigas Iahn, Mahavadi Anil K, Shah Ashish H, Abitbol Nathalie, Komotar Ricardo J
Department of Anesthesiology, Pain Management and Perioperative Medicine, University of Miami, 1400 NW 12th Avenue, Suite 3075, Miami, FL 33136, United States of America.
Division of Management Consulting, Department of Anesthesia, University of Iowa, 200 Hawkins Drive, 6-JCP, Iowa City, IA 52242, United States of America.
J Clin Anesth. 2020 Mar;60:118-124. doi: 10.1016/j.jclinane.2019.09.003. Epub 2019 Oct 24.
We consider the effect of the number of previous interactions between the anesthesia provider and a single neurosurgeon during neurosurgical procedures ("familiarity") and occurrence of an interval ≥15 min from the end of surgery (i.e., dressings applied) to tracheal extubation ("prolonged extubation") during subsequent glioma procedures by that neurosurgeon. The value of 15min is a threshold at which post-case activity by non-anesthesia personnel in the operating room ends.
Historical observational study.
Neurosurgical operating room suite in an academic teaching hospital.
294 patients undergoing elective supratentorial glioma surgery between 2012 and 2017 by a single neurosurgeon.
Anesthesia providers (nurse anesthetists or anesthesia residents) were considered "unfamiliar" with the neurosurgeon if they had been present at the time of extubation for <5 previous neurosurgical cases (including glioma and non-glioma surgery) performed by the neurosurgeon during the study interval. For approximately half the cases the anesthesia provider was unfamiliar with the neurosurgeon. There was an association between the provider's number of historical cases with the neurosurgeon and prolonged extubation (P = 0.0048); the adjusted odds ratio (by unadjusted logistic regression) for unfamiliarity was 2.10 (95% CI 1.28 to 3.44, P = 0.025). Consistent with previously shown associations between case duration and prolonged extubation, analyses were valid based on a near-linear relationship between the logit (prevalence of prolonged extubation) and the case duration quintile.
Lack of familiarity between the anesthesia provider and neurosurgeon during previous anesthetics is associated with prolonged tracheal extubation following intracranial glioblastoma surgery.
我们考察了麻醉医生与同一位神经外科医生在神经外科手术过程中既往互动次数(“熟悉程度”)的影响,以及该神经外科医生随后进行的胶质瘤手术中从手术结束(即敷料应用)至气管拔管间隔≥15分钟(即“延迟拔管”)情况的发生。15分钟这一数值是手术室非麻醉人员术后活动结束的一个阈值。
回顾性观察研究。
一所学术教学医院的神经外科手术室套房。
2012年至2017年间由同一位神经外科医生进行幕上胶质瘤择期手术的294例患者。
1)从手术结束(“敷料应用”)至拔管的时间;2)麻醉医生在该神经外科医生进行的神经外科手术结束时曾参与的既往病例数;3)病例持续时间。
如果麻醉医生(麻醉护士或麻醉住院医师)在研究期间该神经外科医生进行的既往神经外科手术(包括胶质瘤和非胶质瘤手术)拔管时参与的病例数<5例,则被认为与该神经外科医生“不熟悉”。大约一半的病例中麻醉医生与该神经外科医生不熟悉。麻醉医生与该神经外科医生的既往病例数与延迟拔管之间存在关联(P = 0.0048);不熟悉的校正优势比(通过未校正的逻辑回归)为2.10(95%置信区间1.28至3.44,P = 0.025)。与先前显示的病例持续时间与延迟拔管之间的关联一致,基于logit(延迟拔管患病率)与病例持续时间五分位数之间的近似线性关系,分析有效。
麻醉医生与神经外科医生在既往麻醉过程中缺乏熟悉程度与颅内胶质母细胞瘤手术后气管延迟拔管有关。