MINES ParisTech, PSL Research University, CTP - Centre Thermodynamique des Procédés, 35 rue Saint-Honoré, 77300 Fontainebleau, France.
Univ. Lille, CNRS, UMR 8523 - PhLAM - Physique des Lasers Atomes et Molécules, F-59000 Lille, France.
J Chem Phys. 2019 Nov 7;151(17):174504. doi: 10.1063/1.5109777.
We estimate both single ion hydration Gibbs free energies in water droplets, comprising from 50 to 1000 molecules, and water/vacuum surface potentials in pure water droplets comprising up to 10 000 molecules. We consider four ions, namely, Li, NH , F, and Cl, and we model their hydration process and water/water interactions using polarizable force fields based on an induced point dipole approach. We show both ion hydration Gibbs free energies and water surface potentials to obey linear functions of the droplet radius as soon as droplets comprising a few hundred water molecules. Moreover, we also show that the differences in anion/cation hydration Gibbs free energies in droplets obey a different regime in large droplets than in small clusters comprising no more than six water molecules, in line with the earlier results computed from standard additive point charge force fields. Hence, both point charge and more sophisticated induced point dipole molecular modeling approaches suggest that methods considering only the thermodynamical properties of small ion/water clusters to estimate the absolute proton hydration Gibbs free energy in solution are questionable. In particular, taking into account the data of large ion/water droplets may yield a proton hydration Gibbs free energy in solution value to be shifted by several kT units compared to small clusters-based approaches.
我们估计了包含 50 到 1000 个分子的水滴中的单个离子水合吉布斯自由能,以及包含多达 10000 个分子的纯水水滴中的水/真空表面电势。我们考虑了四种离子,即 Li、NH 、F 和 Cl,并使用基于感应点偶极子方法的极化力场来模拟它们的水合过程和水/水相互作用。我们表明,一旦水滴包含几百个水分子,离子水合吉布斯自由能和水表面电势都服从于线性函数的半径。此外,我们还表明,在大液滴中,阴离子/阳离子水合吉布斯自由能的差异遵循与小簇(不超过六个水分子)不同的规则,这与从标准加和点电荷力场计算的早期结果一致。因此,无论是点电荷还是更复杂的感应点偶极子分子建模方法都表明,仅考虑小离子/水簇的热力学性质来估计溶液中绝对质子水合吉布斯自由能的方法是值得怀疑的。特别是,考虑到大离子/水液滴的数据可能会导致溶液中质子水合吉布斯自由能值与基于小簇的方法相比发生几个 kT 单位的偏移。