Upadhyay Aparaajita, Zaidi Asiya Kamber, Mundra R K
Department of ENT, MGM and MY Hospital, Indore, M.P. India.
Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2019 Oct;71(Suppl 1):515-521. doi: 10.1007/s12070-018-1377-5. Epub 2018 Apr 30.
Benign vocal fold lesions (BVFL) frequently affect the general population and cause significant hoarseness by interfering with daily communication. Healthcare for low income groups in India is all about affordability and availability without giving up on quality and providing maximum satisfaction. (1) To analyse over a period of 4 years, the demographics, clinical profile, diagnostics and management options of BVFL. (2) To assess the diagnostic potential of rigid laryngoscopy in diagnosing these lesions. (3) Cold knife endolaryngeal surgery as a cost effective, satisfactory and efficient treatment modality to tackle majority of these BVFL. A prospective cross sectional study over a period of 4 years from 2013 to 2017. 114 patients presenting with hoarseness of voice were evaluated by indirect laryngoscopy followed by video laryngoscopy and stroboscopy in the department of ENT, MYH Hospital Indore (M.P.). Male:female ratio of 1.59:1 with male predominance (61.4%) and maximum incidence in the third decade (32%). All cases presented with hoarseness (100%) while vocal fatigue (63%) was the most common associated complaint followed by foreign body sensation (60%). Housewives (32%) were most commonly involved non professional group while teachers (13%) constituted the most common group of professionals. Laryngitis (26%) involving bilateral vocal folds diffusely was the most common finding followed by vocal fold sulcus (18%) and vocal fold cysts (14%). The duration of symptom was 6 months to 1 year in 52% patients. The positive predictive value for rigid laryngoscopy was 100% for vocal nodules, arytenoid granulomas and anterior glottis web. Out of 114 patients, 66 patients improved on conservative management while 48 patients underwent cold knife endolaryngeal surgery. As per the GRBAS scale to assess the post therapeutic prognosis, all had good outcome of voice with only two recurrences due to patient non compliance. In this rapidly evolving era of sophisticated lasers which is a costly affair that requires skilled personnel and safety precautions, the prime goal in a government run setup has always been to provide affordable and quality healthcare to the common man. Cold knife endolaryngeal surgery is a simple, cost effective and efficient way to tackle most of these lesions and hence helps in achieving this goal.
良性声带病变(BVFL)经常影响普通人群,并通过干扰日常交流导致严重的声音嘶哑。印度低收入群体的医疗保健主要关注可负担性和可及性,同时不放弃质量并提供最大程度的满意度。(1)分析4年间BVFL的人口统计学、临床特征、诊断方法和治疗选择。(2)评估硬质喉镜在诊断这些病变中的诊断潜力。(3)冷刀喉内手术作为一种经济有效、令人满意且高效的治疗方式,用于处理大多数此类BVFL。对2013年至2017年的4年间进行一项前瞻性横断面研究。在印多尔(中央邦)MYH医院耳鼻喉科,对114例声音嘶哑患者进行了间接喉镜检查,随后进行了视频喉镜检查和频闪喉镜检查。男女比例为1.59:1,男性占主导(61.4%),第三十年发病率最高(32%)。所有病例均表现为声音嘶哑(100%),而声音疲劳(63%)是最常见的相关症状,其次是异物感(60%)。家庭主妇(32%)是最常受累的非专业群体,而教师(13%)是最常见的专业群体。弥漫性累及双侧声带的喉炎(26%)是最常见的发现,其次是声带沟(18%)和声带囊肿(14%)。52%的患者症状持续时间为6个月至1年。硬质喉镜对声带小结、杓状软骨肉芽肿和前声门蹼的阳性预测值为100%。114例患者中,66例经保守治疗后病情改善,48例接受了冷刀喉内手术。根据GRBAS量表评估治疗后的预后,所有患者声音预后良好,仅2例因患者不依从而复发。在这个复杂激光技术迅速发展的时代,激光治疗成本高昂,需要技术人员和安全预防措施,在政府运营的医疗机构中,首要目标始终是为普通人提供可负担的优质医疗保健。冷刀喉内手术是处理大多数此类病变的一种简单、经济有效且高效的方法,因此有助于实现这一目标。