School of Nursing and Midwifery, National University of Ireland, Galway, Ireland.
Programme for Health Service Improvement, Health Service Executive, Dublin, Ireland.
Women Birth. 2020 Sep;33(5):419-425. doi: 10.1016/j.wombi.2019.11.001. Epub 2019 Nov 18.
Despite many countries employing the use of national and large scale regional surveys to explore women's experiences of their maternity care, with the results informing national maternity policy and practice, the concept itself is ambiguous and ill-defined having not been subject of a structured concept development endeavour.
The aim of this review is to report on an in-depth analysis conducted on the concept of 'women's experiences of their maternity care'.
Using the principle-based method of concept analysis by Penrod and Hupcey (2005), the concept of 'women's experiences of their maternity care' was analysed under the epistemological, pragmatic, linguistic and logical principles. The final dataset included 87 items of literature published between 1990 and 2017 retrieved from a systematic search of the MEDLINE, CINAHL, EMBASE and PSYCinfo databases.
The epistemological principle identified that a theoretical definition of the concept is elusive with a variety of implicit meanings. The pragmatic principle supports the utility of the concept in scientific literature, however the lack of a theoretical definition has led to inconsistent use of the concept, as highlighted by the linguistic principle. Furthermore, the logical principle highlighted that as the concept lacks definition blurring is identifiable when theoretically positioned with related concepts.
The outcome of this concept analysis is a theoretical definition of a previously undefined concept. This definition highlights the subjective nature of the concept, its dependency upon a woman's individual needs, expectations and circumstances and the influence of the organisation and delivery of maternity care.
尽管许多国家采用国家和大规模区域调查来探索妇女对其分娩护理的体验,调查结果为国家产科学政策和实践提供信息,但该概念本身是模糊和未明确定义的,因为它尚未经过结构化的概念发展努力。
本综述旨在报告对“妇女对其分娩护理的体验”这一概念进行的深入分析。
使用 Penrod 和 Hupcey(2005 年)提出的基于原则的概念分析方法,根据认识论、实用主义、语言学和逻辑原则对“妇女对其分娩护理的体验”这一概念进行分析。最终数据集包括从 MEDLINE、CINAHL、EMBASE 和 PSYCinfo 数据库进行系统检索后获得的 1990 年至 2017 年间发表的 87 篇文献。
认识论原则表明,该概念的理论定义难以捉摸,具有多种隐含意义。实用主义原则支持该概念在科学文献中的实用性,但是缺乏理论定义导致该概念的使用不一致,这一点在语言学原则中得到了强调。此外,逻辑原则强调,由于该概念缺乏定义,当从理论上与相关概念进行定位时,概念模糊性是显而易见的。
本次概念分析的结果是对以前未定义概念的理论定义。该定义突出了该概念的主观性,其依赖于妇女的个人需求、期望和环境,以及分娩护理的组织和提供方式。