Dr. Ash is Professor and Director, Psychiatry and Law Service, Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia. Ms. Roberts is Court Liaison Director, Psychiatry and Law Service, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia. Dr. Egan is Assistant Professor, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia. Dr. Coffman is Assistant Professor and Medical Director, Fulton County Jail Competency Restoration Unit, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia. Dr. Schwenke is Assistant Professor and Program Director, Fulton County Jail Competency Restoration Unit, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia. Dr. Bailey is Director of Forensic Services, Georgia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Disabilities, Atlanta, Georgia.
J Am Acad Psychiatry Law. 2020 Mar;48(1):43-51. doi: 10.29158/JAAPL.003893-20. Epub 2019 Nov 21.
This study reports on restoration outcomes of a sample of pretrial defendants ( = 877, 69% male) who were found incompetent to stand trial and underwent restoration services in a large urban county. Each male defendant was initially assigned to restoration in one of four settings on a continuum of services of varying intensity (ie, outpatient, jail general population, dedicated jail-based restoration unit, or forensic hospital inpatient unit) based on the defendant's assessed clinical need. Of those who received services on the jail-based restoration unit ( = 398), 40 percent were restored to competency, 31 percent were diverted out of the criminal justice system, and 29 percent were referred for more intensive inpatient services, primarily because of refusal of medication (i.e., the jail would not allow involuntary medication, even if court-ordered). Advantages of restoration on the jail unit compared with inpatient hospitalization included more rapid institution of restoration services and higher rates of diversion out of the criminal justice system at one-third of the cost of inpatient restoration services. A continuum of restoration services that allows the type of restoration service to be matched to the needs of the individual incompetent defendant has significant advantages over routine transfer to a forensic hospital for restoration.
本研究报告了一项针对审前被告(=877,69%为男性)的康复结果,这些被告被发现无能力接受审判,并在一个大城市县接受了康复服务。每个男性被告最初根据其临床评估的需要,被分配到服务连续性中的四个康复环境之一,服务的强度不同(即门诊、监狱普通人群、专门的监狱康复单元或法医医院住院单元)。在接受监狱康复单元服务的那些人(=398)中,有 40%的人恢复了能力,31%的人被转出刑事司法系统,29%的人被转介到更密集的住院服务,主要是因为拒绝药物治疗(即监狱不允许非自愿药物治疗,即使是法院命令的)。与住院治疗相比,在监狱单元进行康复的优势包括更快地提供康复服务,以及以三分之一的住院康复服务成本将更多的人从刑事司法系统中转出。提供康复服务的连续性,使康复服务的类型能够与个别无能力被告的需求相匹配,与常规转介到法医医院进行康复相比具有显著优势。