Patnaik Uma, Panda Smriti, Thakar Alok
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Army Hospital, Research and Referral, New Delhi, India.
J Neurol Surg B Skull Base. 2019 Dec;80(6):586-592. doi: 10.1055/s-0038-1676793. Epub 2018 Dec 26.
This study was aimed to classify and study complications of surgery of the cranial base, primarily from an otorhinolaryngology perspective. This study was designed with consecutive cohort of skull base surgical cases. Tertiary referral academic center. Patients having skull-base surgery at a otorhinolaryngology based skull-base unit, from 2002 to 2015. Enumeration of complications is the main outcome of this study. Surgical procedures, categorized for complexity as per a unified system, are applicable to endoscopic and open procedures. Complications were categorized as per the British Association of Otolaryngologists coding of surgical complications. Complication classified as major if life-threatening, causing permanent disability, or compromising the result of surgery. A total of 342 patients ( = 342) were operated; 13 patients' records were excluded due to < 6 months posttreatment follow-up. The study group constituted 204 anterior skull-base (endoscopic, 120; open/external, 84) and 125 lateral skull-base procedures. Complication rates noted to increase in both groups with increasing complexity of surgical intervention. Anterior skull-base surgery (total complications, 11%; major, 3%; death, 0.5%) noted to have significantly less surgical complications than lateral skull-base surgery (total complications, 33%; major, 15%; death, 1.6%; < 0.001). Among the anterior procedures no significant difference noted among endoscopic and external approaches when compared across similar surgical complexity. Despite improvement in surgical and perioperative care, the overall major complication rate in a contemporary otolaryngology led, primarily extradural, skull-base practice is noted at 8%. Perioperative mortality, though rare, was encountered in 1%. A standard method for categorization of surgical complexity and the grade of complications as reported here is recommended.
本研究旨在主要从耳鼻咽喉科角度对颅底手术并发症进行分类和研究。 本研究设计为连续队列的颅底手术病例。 三级转诊学术中心。 2002年至2015年期间在以耳鼻咽喉科为基础的颅底科室接受颅底手术的患者。 并发症的计数是本研究的主要结果。根据统一系统分类为复杂程度的手术程序适用于内镜手术和开放手术。并发症根据英国耳鼻咽喉科协会的手术并发症编码进行分类。如果并发症危及生命、导致永久性残疾或影响手术结果,则分类为主要并发症。 共有342例患者(n = 342)接受了手术;13例患者的记录因治疗后随访时间不足6个月而被排除。研究组包括204例前颅底手术(内镜手术120例;开放/外入路手术84例)和125例侧颅底手术。随着手术干预复杂性的增加,两组的并发症发生率均有所上升。前颅底手术(总并发症发生率为11%;主要并发症发生率为3%;死亡率为0.5%)的手术并发症明显少于侧颅底手术(总并发症发生率为33%;主要并发症发生率为15%;死亡率为1.6%;P < 0.001)。在前颅底手术中,当比较相似手术复杂性时,内镜手术和外入路手术之间未发现显著差异。 尽管手术和围手术期护理有所改善,但在当代主要由耳鼻咽喉科主导的、主要为硬膜外的颅底手术实践中,总体主要并发症发生率仍为8%。围手术期死亡率虽然罕见,但为1%。建议采用本文报道的手术复杂性分类和并发症分级的标准方法。