Decker R, Ruf W
Chirurgische Universitätsklinik Heidelberg.
Unfallchirurgie. 1988 Aug;14(4):204-10.
The prognosis of knee ligament injury is mainly dependent on early diagnosis. In a prospective trial comprising 108 patients with fresh injury of the knee ligaments, the prognostic value of clinical non-invasive examination were assessed in awake and anesthetized patients. As a result the merely clinical examination without anesthesia gave only in 48% a diagnosis reliably enough for operation indication. Examination under anesthesia detected more than 83% of injuries with need for operation and 90% of ruptures of the anterior cruciate ligament. Lachman-test proved to be very reliable (more than 90%) and lateral pivot-shift-phenomenon almost provable (more than 86%) for ligament rupture. Arthroscopy in our hands is playing only a minor role at the event of fresh injury of the knee ligaments. In only 10% it was the decisive tool for operation. In our opinion the indication for narcosis examination should be put widely due to its high sensitivity. Since in approximately 90% on additional arthroscopy can be resigned, the entire ischemia time during pneumatic blood circulation blockage (110 to 120 min) is available for operative reconstruction of the knee joint.
膝关节韧带损伤的预后主要取决于早期诊断。在一项包含108例新鲜膝关节韧带损伤患者的前瞻性试验中,对清醒和麻醉状态下患者的临床无创检查的预后价值进行了评估。结果显示,仅进行无麻醉的临床检查时,只有48%的情况能可靠地做出足以作为手术指征的诊断。麻醉下检查能检测出超过83%需要手术的损伤以及90%的前交叉韧带断裂。对于韧带断裂,拉赫曼试验被证明非常可靠(超过90%),外侧轴移现象几乎可确诊(超过86%)。在我们的经验中,关节镜检查在新鲜膝关节韧带损伤时仅起次要作用。仅在10%的情况下它是手术的决定性工具。我们认为,由于麻醉检查具有高敏感性,其指征应广泛应用。因为大约90%的情况可无需额外进行关节镜检查,所以在气动血液循环阻断期间的整个缺血时间(110至120分钟)可用于膝关节的手术重建。