Sophiahemmet University, Stockholm, Sweden.
The Swedish Red Cross University College, Huddinge, Sweden.
Reprod Health. 2019 Nov 27;16(1):172. doi: 10.1186/s12978-019-0835-1.
Today, there are various short- and long-acting contraceptive alternatives available for those who wish to prevent unintended pregnancy. Long-acting reversible contraception are considered effective methods with a high user satisfaction. High-quality information about contraception is essential in order to empower individuals to reach informed decisions based on sufficient knowledge. Use of the Web for information about contraception is widespread, and there is a risk that those who use it for this purpose could come in contact with sources of low quality.
The overarching aim was to investigate the quality of websites about long-acting reversible contraception.
Swedish client-oriented websites were identified through searches in Google (n = 46 included websites). Reliability and information about long-acting reversible contraceptive choices were assessed by two assessors with the DISCERN instrument, transparency was analyzed with the Journal of the American Medical Association benchmarks, completeness was assessed with inductive content analysis and readability was analyzed with Readability Index.
The mean DISCERN was 44.1/80 (SD 7.7) for total score, 19.7/40 (SD 3.7) for reliability, 22.1/35 (SD 4.1) for information about long-acting reversible contraceptive choices, and 2.3/5 (SD 1.1) for overall quality. A majority of the included websites had low quality with regard to what sources were used to compile the information (n = 41/46, 89%), when the information was produced (n = 40/46, 87%), and if it provided additional sources of support and information (n = 30/46, 65%). Less than half of the websites adhered to any of the JAMA benchmarks. We identified 23 categories of comprehensiveness. The most frequent was contraceptive mechanism (n = 39/46, 85%) and the least frequent was when contraception may be initiated following an abortion (n = 3/46, 7%). The mean Readability Index was 42.5 (SD 6.3, Range 29-55) indicating moderate to difficult readability levels, corresponding to a grade level of 9.
The quality of client-oriented websites about long-acting reversible contraception is poor. There is an undeniable need to support and guide laypersons that intend to use web-based sources about contraceptive alternatives, so that they may reach informed decisions based on sufficient knowledge.
如今,有各种短期和长期避孕选择可供那些希望避免意外怀孕的人使用。长效可逆避孕方法被认为是有效且用户满意度高的方法。为了使个人能够根据充分的知识做出明智的决定,提供关于避孕的高质量信息至关重要。人们广泛使用网络获取避孕信息,但也存在风险,即那些出于此目的使用网络的人可能会接触到低质量的信息源。
本研究旨在调查长效可逆避孕相关网站的质量。
通过在 Google 中搜索(共纳入 46 个相关网站),确定瑞典面向客户的网站。两名评估员使用 DISCERN 工具评估网站的可靠性和关于长效可逆避孕选择的信息,使用《美国医学会杂志》基准分析透明度,使用归纳内容分析评估完整性,使用可读性指数分析可读性。
总评分的平均 DISCERN 为 44.1/80(SD 7.7),可靠性为 19.7/40(SD 3.7),长效可逆避孕选择的信息为 22.1/35(SD 4.1),整体质量为 2.3/5(SD 1.1)。大多数纳入的网站在信息来源(n=41/46,89%)、信息制作时间(n=40/46,87%)和是否提供额外的支持和信息来源(n=30/46,65%)方面质量较低。不到一半的网站符合任何 JAMA 基准。我们确定了 23 个类别的全面性。最常见的是避孕机制(n=39/46,85%),最不常见的是堕胎后何时可以开始避孕(n=3/46,7%)。平均可读性指数为 42.5(SD 6.3,范围 29-55),表明可读性处于中等至困难水平,相当于 9 年级的水平。
面向客户的长效可逆避孕相关网站的质量较差。不可否认的是,需要支持和指导那些打算使用基于网络的避孕替代方法的非专业人士,以便他们能够根据充分的知识做出明智的决定。