Hussain Farhat Naz, Wilby Kyle John
College of Pharmacy, Qatar University, Doha, Qatar.
School of Pharmacy, University of Otago, PO Box 56, Dunedin 9054, New Zealand.
Curr Pharm Teach Learn. 2019 Nov;11(11):1196-1204. doi: 10.1016/j.cptl.2019.07.004. Epub 2019 Aug 10.
Audience response systems (ARS) are increasingly being used to support learning and assessment. Despite widespread use, the effects on educational outcomes and student learning are largely unknown. The objective of this systematic review was to assess the impacts of using ARS in pharmacy education.
A literature search was conducted on PubMed, Embase, Google Scholar, and three pharmacy education journals. Articles were eligible for inclusion if they reported outcomes relating to the use of ARS in student pharmacist education and were published in English.
Eleven studies were included. Endpoints related to course grades, information recall, student perceptions, and faculty perceptions. Few studies were identified that assessed the impact of ARS on course grades and those that did reported mixed results. ARS demonstrated improved student recall immediately following an educational activity but effects were not lasting. Students had positive perceptions regarding ARS classroom use, especially for participation, engagement, and attention to educational content. Faculty members were positive towards the use of ARS for teaching purposes but expressed concerns regarding the use for assessment.
The use of ARS positively benefited student participation and engagement in the classroom setting, as a tool to enhance active learning. Positive perceptions from faculty and feasibility of use also support that ARS may be an effective teaching strategy to better engage students in the learning process. The impact on student academic performance is inconclusive and must be further explored.
观众反应系统(ARS)越来越多地被用于支持学习和评估。尽管其使用广泛,但对教育成果和学生学习的影响在很大程度上仍不明确。本系统评价的目的是评估在药学教育中使用ARS的影响。
在PubMed、Embase、谷歌学术以及三本药学教育期刊上进行文献检索。如果文章报告了与在学生药剂师教育中使用ARS相关的结果且以英文发表,则符合纳入标准。
纳入了11项研究。终点指标涉及课程成绩、信息回忆、学生看法和教师看法。很少有研究评估ARS对课程成绩的影响,且已有的相关研究结果不一。ARS在教育活动后能立即提高学生的信息回忆,但效果不持久。学生对在课堂上使用ARS持积极看法,特别是对于参与度、投入度以及对教育内容的关注度方面。教师对将ARS用于教学目的持积极态度,但对用于评估表示担忧。
ARS的使用对学生在课堂环境中的参与度和投入度有积极作用,可作为增强主动学习的工具。教师的积极看法和使用的可行性也表明,ARS可能是一种有效的教学策略,能更好地让学生参与学习过程。对学生学业成绩的影响尚无定论,必须进一步探索。