Department of Medical Physics, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY, USA.
J Appl Clin Med Phys. 2019 Dec;20(12):180-185. doi: 10.1002/acm2.12759.
In this work, we evaluated the change of primary monitor characteristics in two consecutive years. Sixty-six primary monitors were included in the analysis. The monitors were located at radiology physicians' offices and radiology reading rooms. All primary monitors were equipped with the manufacturer's built-in photometers and connected to the BarcoMediCalQA web service for manual and automatic quality control measurements. External photometer/illuminance meter (RaySafe Solo Light) was used to measure the luminance values. Measured luminance values of the TG18LN1-18 and TG18UNL80 test patterns were used to evaluate the primary monitors performance. In a comparison of the quality assurance (QA) measurement results for the same monitors that were performed within 2 years, the luminance of 25 displays remained statistically the same (P > 0.01). The luminance of 17 displays decreased (P < 0.01) in 2017 when compared with 2016, the luminance of 24 displays increased (P < 0.01) in 2017 when compared with 2016. For the annual measurements of the MLD in 2016 and 2017, 25 out of 66 displays showed a decrease of MLD values in 2017 compared with the same measurements in 2016 and 41 displays showed an increase of MLD in 2017. All tested primary displays had the MLD value less than 17.2%. The mean value of illuminance measured in 2016 was 5.8 lux ± 3.1 lux. In 2017, the mean value of illuminance measured was 8.7 lux ± 5.3 lux. Although it is expected that monitors luminance values will decrease over time, we found displays with increased luminance. This is possibly due to the multiple monitor calibrations that were performed between two annual monitor QA tests. Based on the findings of this work, more efficient display QA programs with a shorter time interval than 1 year are needed.
在这项工作中,我们评估了连续两年中主要监视器特性的变化。共有 66 个主要监视器纳入分析。这些监视器位于放射科医生办公室和放射科阅片室。所有的主要监视器都配备了制造商的内置光度计,并连接到 BarcoMediCalQA 网络服务,以进行手动和自动质量控制测量。使用外部光度计/照度计(RaySafe Solo Light)来测量亮度值。使用 TG18LN1-18 和 TG18UNL80 测试图案的测量亮度值来评估主要监视器的性能。在对两年内对同一监视器进行的质量保证(QA)测量结果进行比较时,25 个显示器的亮度在统计学上保持不变(P>0.01)。与 2016 年相比,2017 年 17 个显示器的亮度降低(P<0.01),与 2016 年相比,24 个显示器的亮度增加(P<0.01)。对于 2016 年和 2017 年的 MLD 年度测量,与 2016 年的相同测量值相比,66 个显示器中有 25 个在 2017 年显示 MLD 值降低,而 41 个显示器显示 MLD 在 2017 年增加。所有经过测试的主要显示器的 MLD 值均小于 17.2%。2016 年测量的照度平均值为 5.8lux±3.1lux。2017 年,测量的照度平均值为 8.7lux±5.3lux。尽管预计监视器亮度值会随时间降低,但我们发现一些显示器的亮度增加了。这可能是由于在两次年度监视器 QA 测试之间进行了多次监视器校准。基于这项工作的结果,需要更有效的显示 QA 计划,其时间间隔短于 1 年。