Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior, Alpert Medical School of Brown University, Providence, RI.
Department of Psychology, University of South Florida, Tampa, FL.
Child Obes. 2020 Apr;16(3):192-203. doi: 10.1089/chi.2019.0053. Epub 2019 Dec 18.
The goal of this randomized controlled trial was to compare the relative effectiveness of a comprehensive lifestyle intervention delivered through the YMCA, , with an enhanced version of this program that included on-site supervised group physical activity and opportunities for peer support, in decreasing adolescent weight status. Sixty-six adolescents with BMI >85th percentile and absolute BMI <50 were randomly assigned to the or the program. Teens in both conditions attended 16 weekly, in-person group sessions, followed by four biweekly and four monthly maintenance sessions. The enhanced condition also included weekly, group-based physical activity sessions and challenges. Group sessions were led by YMCA coaches. Groups did not differ at baseline by age (14.7 + 1.6 years), sex (60.6% female), racial/ethnic minority status (37.7%), or weight (53.0% with severe obesity). Retention was 91% at 16 weeks and 82% at 10 months. Controlling for minority status and sex, there were no significant group differences over time for BMI ( = 0.15), BMI -scores for age and sex (BMIz, = 0.07), or percent overweight ( = 0.15). Across all participants, on average, BMI decreased by 1.4 kg/m, BMIz decreased by 0.12, and percent overweight decreased by 8.8% at four months. There were no significant differences observed in primary outcomes for adolescents randomized to the standard and enhanced versions of the program. Although the absence of a control condition precludes attribution to the intervention, teens in both conditions demonstrated greater decreases in weight status than what was observed in an open trial of the original program.
本随机对照试验的目的是比较通过基督教青年会提供的综合生活方式干预与强化版该计划的相对有效性,强化版计划包括现场监督的小组体育活动和同伴支持机会,以降低青少年的体重状况。66 名 BMI>第 85 百分位且绝对 BMI<50 的青少年被随机分配到或计划。两种情况下的青少年都参加了 16 次每周一次的面对面小组会议,随后是四次每两周一次和四次每月维持会议。强化条件还包括每周一次的小组体育活动和挑战。小组会议由基督教青年会教练带领。在基线时,两组在年龄(14.7+1.6 岁)、性别(60.6%女性)、少数族裔地位(37.7%)或体重(53.0%严重肥胖)方面没有差异。16 周时的保留率为 91%,10 个月时为 82%。控制少数族裔地位和性别,BMI 随时间没有显著组间差异(=0.15),BMI 年龄和性别得分(BMIz,=0.07),或超重百分比(=0.15)。在所有参与者中,平均而言,BMI 下降了 1.4kg/m,BMIz 下降了 0.12,超重百分比下降了 8.8%,在四个月时。随机分配到标准和强化版计划的青少年在主要结果上没有观察到显著差异。尽管缺乏对照条件,无法归因于干预措施,但两种情况下的青少年体重状况的下降幅度均大于原始计划的开放试验中观察到的下降幅度。