Hanaiwa Hiroki, Narita Taeko, Kato Kyohei, Yokoo Atsumi, Shinto Kazuhiro, Funashima Yumiko, Sato Kenichi, Nagasawa Zenzo, Umemura Tsukuru
Departmemt of Clinical Laboratory, Medical Kouhoukai Takagi Hospital, Sakemi 141-11, Okawa, Fukuoka 831-0016, Japan.
Departmemt of Medical Technology and Science, International University of Health and Welfare, Enokidu 137-1, Okawa, Fukuoka 831-8501, Japan.
Rinsho Biseibutshu Jinsoku Shindan Kenkyukai Shi. 2019 Dec 25;29(1):1-9.
Identification of bacteria by using MALDI Biotyper is relevant at the species category if Score Value (SV) is not less than 2.000. However, in practical examination, the analysis by MALDI Biotyper frequently produces the multiple candidate bacterial species with SV ≥2.000. In this study, we analyzed the ratio of multiple results among 10,081 specimens and identified the species of bacteria with high frequency of multiple results. Our analysis indicated that 8,129 strains out of 10,081 strains examined from July 2015 to July 2017, showed multiple identification results with MALDI Biotyper, and that multiple result was obtained in 4.9% of gram positive cocci analysis, 5.8% of gram positive rods, 25.4% of gram negative cocci, 16% of gram negative rod, none of fungus. In particular, MALDI Biotyper analysis of spp. (, , , etc.), spp. (, , etc.), spp. (, etc.) had high ratios of multiple results. Our data suggests that genetic homology among bacteria results in multiple results of bacteria identification. The mass spectrometer method is the rapid test for bacteria identification. However, for obtaining higher specificity, it is required to combine with other methods. Furthermore, systematic annotation of bacteria is highly recommended.
如果得分值(SV)不低于2.000,使用基质辅助激光解吸电离飞行时间质谱仪(MALDI Biotyper)鉴定细菌在种的分类上是可靠的。然而,在实际检测中,MALDI Biotyper分析经常会产生多个SV≥2.000的候选细菌种类。在本研究中,我们分析了10081份标本中出现多个结果的比例,并确定了出现多个结果频率较高的细菌种类。我们的分析表明,在2015年7月至2017年7月检测的10081株菌株中,有8129株通过MALDI Biotyper显示出多个鉴定结果,其中革兰氏阳性球菌分析中有4.9%出现多个结果,革兰氏阳性杆菌中有5.8%,革兰氏阴性球菌中有25.4%,革兰氏阴性杆菌中有16%,真菌检测中未出现多个结果。特别是,对某些菌属(如[具体菌属1]、[具体菌属2]、[具体菌属3]等)、某些菌属(如[具体菌属4]、[具体菌属5]、[具体菌属6]等)、某些菌属(如[具体菌属7]、[具体菌属8]等)的MALDI Biotyper分析出现多个结果的比例较高。我们的数据表明,细菌之间的基因同源性导致了细菌鉴定出现多个结果。质谱仪方法是细菌鉴定的快速检测方法。然而,为了获得更高的特异性,需要与其他方法相结合。此外,强烈建议对细菌进行系统注释。