Department of Neurology, The Second Hospital of Hebei Medical University, 215 Heping West Road, Shijiazhuang, 050000, China.
BMC Neurol. 2019 Dec 19;19(1):331. doi: 10.1186/s12883-019-1554-5.
Meningeal carcinomatosis (MC) is the most severe form of brain metastasis and causes significant morbidity and mortality. Currently, the diagnosis of MC is routinely confirmed on the basis of clinical manifestation, positive cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) cytology, and/or neuroimaging features. However, negative rate of CSF cytology and neuroimaging findings often result in a failure to diagnose MC from the patients who actually have the disease. Here we evaluate the CSF circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) in the diagnosis of MC.
A total of 35 CSF samples were collected from 35 patients with MC for CSF cytology examination, CSF ctDNA extraction and cancer-associated gene mutations detection by next-generation sequencing (NGS) at the same time.
The most frequent primary tumor in this study was lung cancer (26/35, 74%), followed by gastric cancer (2/35, 6%), breast cancer (2/35, 6%), prostatic cancer (1/35, 3%), parotid gland carcinoma (1/35, 3%) and lymphoma (1/35, 3%) while no primary tumor could be found in the remaining 2 patients in spite of using various inspection methods. Twenty-five CSF samples (25/35; 71%) were found neoplastic cells in CSF cytology examination while all of the 35 CSF samples (35/35; 100%) were revealed having detectable ctDNA in which cancer-associated gene mutations were detected. All of 35 patients with MC in the study underwent contrast-enhanced brain MRI and/or CT and 22 neuroimaging features (22/35; 63%) were consistent with MC. The sensitivity of the neuroimaging was 88% (95% confidence intervals [95% CI], 75 to 100) (p = 22/25) and 63% (95% CI, 47 to 79) (p = 22/35) compared to those of CSF cytology and CSF ctDNA, respectively. The sensitivity of the CSF cytology was 71% (95% CI, 56 to 86) (n = 25/35) compared to that of CSF ctDNA.
This study suggests a higher sensitivity of CSF ctDNA than those of CSF cytology and neuroimaging findings. We find cancer-associated gene mutations in ctDNA from CSF of patients with MC at 100% of our cohort, and utilizing CSF ctDNA as liquid biopsy technology based on the detection of cancer-associated gene mutations may give additional information to diagnose MC with negative CSF cytology and/or negative neuroimaging findings.
脑膜癌病(MC)是脑转移中最严重的形式,导致显著的发病率和死亡率。目前,MC 的诊断通常基于临床表现、脑脊液(CSF)细胞学阳性和/或神经影像学特征。然而,CSF 细胞学和神经影像学检查的阴性率常常导致实际上患有该疾病的患者未能得到诊断。在这里,我们评估了 CSF 循环肿瘤 DNA(ctDNA)在 MC 诊断中的应用。
我们同时对 35 例 MC 患者的 35 份 CSF 样本进行了 CSF 细胞学检查、CSF ctDNA 提取和下一代测序(NGS)检测癌症相关基因突变。
在这项研究中,最常见的原发性肿瘤是肺癌(26/35,74%),其次是胃癌(2/35,6%)、乳腺癌(2/35,6%)、前列腺癌(1/35,3%)、腮腺癌(1/35,3%)和淋巴瘤(1/35,3%),而其余 2 名患者尽管使用了各种检查方法,仍未发现原发性肿瘤。25 份 CSF 样本(25/35;71%)在 CSF 细胞学检查中发现了肿瘤细胞,而 35 份 CSF 样本(35/35;100%)均显示存在可检测的 ctDNA,其中检测到癌症相关基因突变。所有 35 例 MC 患者均进行了增强脑 MRI 和/或 CT 检查,22 项神经影像学特征(22/35;63%)与 MC 一致。神经影像学的灵敏度为 88%(95%置信区间[95%CI],75 至 100)(p=22/25)和 63%(95%CI,47 至 79)(p=22/35),分别高于 CSF 细胞学和 CSF ctDNA 的灵敏度。CSF 细胞学的灵敏度为 71%(95%CI,56 至 86)(n=25/35),高于 CSF ctDNA。
本研究表明 CSF ctDNA 的灵敏度高于 CSF 细胞学和神经影像学检查。我们在我们的队列中 100%的 MC 患者的 CSF 中发现了 ctDNA 中的癌症相关基因突变,并且利用基于癌症相关基因突变检测的 CSF ctDNA 作为液体活检技术,可能会提供额外的信息来诊断 CSF 细胞学和/或神经影像学检查阴性的 MC。