State Key Laboratory of Pollution Control & Resource Reuse, School of the Environment, Nanjing University, Nanjing, 210023, PR China.
State Key Laboratory of Pollution Control & Resource Reuse, School of the Environment, Nanjing University, Nanjing, 210023, PR China.
Chemosphere. 2020 Apr;245:125632. doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2019.125632. Epub 2019 Dec 12.
Mechanistic information is essential to screen and predict the adverse effects of a large number of chemicals during early-life exposure. Concentration-dependent omics can capture the extent of perturbations of biological pathways or processes and provide information on the mechanism of toxicity. However, the application of concentration-dependent transcriptome to assess the developmental toxicity of environmental chemicals is still limited. Here, twelve chemicals representing five different modes of action (MOAs) were tested by the concentration-dependent reduced zebrafish transcriptome approach (CRZT) in combination with a phenotype-based high content screen (PHCS). The responsiveness, sensitivity and mechanistic differentiation of CRZT were validated in comparison with PHCS. First, PHCS identified 10 chemicals with obvious embryotoxicity (LD range: 2.11-70.68 μM), while the potencies of the biological pathways perturbed by 12 chemicals (POD range: 0.002-2.1 μM) were demonstrated by CRZT. Second, although the potency of the transcriptome perturbations was positively correlated with lethality (LD) (R = 0.64, P-value < 0.05) for most tested chemicals, BbF was non-embryotoxic but was the most potent on the perturbance of biological pathways. Finally, the profiles of the perturbed biological processes and the transcriptome potency (POD) captured by CRZT could effectively classify most chemicals corresponding to their known MOAs. In summary, CRZT could significantly improve testing the developmental toxicity of environmental chemicals.
机制信息对于筛选和预测大量化学物质在生命早期暴露时的不良影响至关重要。浓度依赖性组学可以捕捉生物途径或过程的扰动程度,并提供毒性机制的信息。然而,浓度依赖性转录组学在评估环境化学物的发育毒性方面的应用仍然有限。在这里,采用浓度依赖性减少斑马鱼转录组方法(CRZT)与表型为基础的高通量筛选(PHCS)相结合,测试了 12 种代表 5 种不同作用模式(MOA)的化学物质。CRZT 的反应性、敏感性和机制区分能力与 PHCS 进行了比较验证。首先,PHCS 鉴定出 10 种具有明显胚胎毒性的化学物质(LD 范围:2.11-70.68μM),而 12 种化学物质干扰的生物途径的效力(POD 范围:0.002-2.1μM)通过 CRZT 得到证实。其次,尽管大多数测试化学物质的转录组扰动效力与致死率(LD)呈正相关(R=0.64,P 值<0.05),但 BbF 没有胚胎毒性,但在干扰生物途径方面最有效。最后,CRZT 捕获的扰动生物过程和转录组效力(POD)的图谱可以有效地对大多数已知 MOA 的化学物质进行分类。总之,CRZT 可以显著提高环境化学物发育毒性的测试能力。